Games where evil playthroughs don't suck

[Oyster Sauce]

Been feeling goth lately. What games have satisfying evil playthroughs? I hear you miss a lot of the content if you do bad deeds in BG3.

[Acrux]

Giving you a friendly for tag trolling. We don't see enough of that around here.

[wndrbr]

I heard MotB and KOTOR2 had good evil playthroughs. I never played them as an evil character, though.

[Vergil]

Dark Messiah of Might and Magic has a pretty good evil ending that's arguably better than the good one. Not a lot of choices before the few ending ones though.

[rusty_shackleford]

Destroy all humans

[Oyster Sauce]

I've seen many a post throughout the ages claiming that Jade Empire has the most evil ending ever. Tried playing it a few times but it never stuck.

[Vergil]

KOTOR2 had good evil playthroughs.

While it's definitely better than the first game it does still occasionally run into the "Be Jesus saving kittens or the devil kicking kittens" issue. A lot of the moral encounters are definitely set up in a way so you have to be either typical Jedi or typical Sith so that Kreia can give a meta commentary.
Still one of my top 3 favorite games of all time though.

[rusty_shackleford]

No game where you can choose to do good or do bad will be satisfying to play as evil.

[Anon]

No game where you can choose to do good or do bad will be satisfying to play as evil.

Agreed. I have never found a game where going evil was "optimal" or even comparable as playing good or neutral. You're always losing out significantly.

[Oyster Sauce]

No game where you can choose to do good or do bad will be satisfying to play as evil.

Somebody has clearly never had a dark side Bastila gf

[The_Mask]

Any game after 2017 basically, because as the bad guy you just get to kill all the SJWs. In WOTR, if you play Swarm, all you do is kill all the trash in the world. Pretty much same with Lich.

[Vergil]

No game where you can choose to do good or do bad will be satisfying to play as evil.

Agreed. I have never found a game where going evil was "optimal" or even comparable as playing good or neutral. You're always losing out significantly.

This was always a big problem for me and why I wish games would let you delve into your character's reasonings a bit more. Often times I end up doing "good" guy routes but only because it's the pragmatic thing to do for maximum reward. If a setting (like Star Wars) is going to present going evil as some seductive easy path to money/power/prestige at the cost of your soul/whatever then evil options should be the optimum path from a pragmatic materialistic viewpoint.
KOTOR II at least touches on this sometimes like letting you be nice and good to your companions so you can manipulate their feelings to push them to the dark side.

[Tweed]

Without giving any real spoilers and thus no real information:

Dark Messiah of Might and Magic it's all too obvious which ending Arkane wants you to take and it's quite satisfying.

The dark path in Lands of Lore 2 is arguably more fun than the normal playthrough and Dawn dresses like a slut to try and seduce you later.

The evil path in Geneforge and its ending feel great.

[Watser]

The evil path in Geneforge 2 is arguably the good ending.

[Rand]

The game Tyranny, maybe?

[Rand]

The evil path in Geneforge 2 is arguably the good ending.

I ALWAYS side with the shapers.
It's made clear that shaping is inherently very dangerous and can lead to evil rapidly. (As it did in the universe of the games.)
And it's too easy for small groups of individuals to amass immense power that they can't control.
The only thing keeping the genie in the bottle was the ruthlessness of the shaper council in eliminating problems.
But they didn't ever go far enough.
Barring Sucia island was a mistake. ALL facilities, including the geneforge itself, should have been destroyed, and also the island should have been scoured of all life.

[Vergil]

The game Tyranny, maybe?

More like Tyranny

[Magick]

Haven't got around to playing it yet but going by Swen's old blogs, didn't they design Divinity Dragon Commander to be more "morally grey"? Where even stuff like rape has "pros and cons", rather than outright lecturing.
I'll be disappointed if they didn't actually follow through on that philosophy. (Not just the rape, I'm not Red7).

[WaterMage]

PF:WoTR.

You get to put a lot of awful NPC's/companions in their place as an lich.

[Marcellus]

Dark Messiah of Might and Magic has a pretty good evil ending that's arguably better than the good one. Not a lot of choices before the few ending ones though.

Games with morally ambiguous endings, such as Dark Messiah of Might and Magic, give richness to player options. While alternatives are limited, taking both the good and bad ways enriches the story.

[Segata]

Games with morally ambiguous endings, such as Dark Messiah of Might and Magic, give richness to player options. While alternatives are limited, taking both the good and bad ways enriches the story.Magic 8 ball online

Hello, can you write '******' in your next post, please? this is to determine whether you're a bot or not. Thanks for cooperating.

[Emphyrio]

Fallout 3, New Vegas

[rusty_shackleford]

Fallout 3, New Vegas

NCR playthrough is the worst one

[Val the Moofia Boss]

I heard Aselia the Spirit of Eternity Sword had an evil route that was cut out of the English release.

[Oyster Sauce]

The game Tyranny, maybe?

Loved when the living incarnation of justice, holder of the highest court in all the lands, merciless executor of Kyros' law immediately bent the knee and betrayed Kyros to swear allegiance to me (while I was trying to be loyal to Kyros???) because my defence when put on trial was "sometimes the ends justify the means hehe"
Oh, and when the game just ******* ended for no reason with them never planning to release a sequel.
The magic customization was fun though.

[Element]

Mask of the Betrayer. Very unique companions and a cool ending as well.

[rusty_shackleford]

Loved when the living incarnation of justice, holder of the highest court in all the lands, merciless executor of Kyros' law immediately bent the knee and betrayed Kyros to swear allegiance to me (while I was trying to be loyal to Kyros???) because my defence when put on trial was "sometimes the ends justify the means hehe"

Pretty sure there's actually a reason for this because the game has a cryptic, hidden meaning about who the protagonist is that you're supposed to piece together but only 2-3 people ever did.
Coincidentally, I think @The_Mask is one of them. So maybe he knows.

[Rand]

Oh, and when the game just ******* ended for no reason with them never planning to release a sequel.

There was a rough-designed sequel, but they didn't do **** until they gauged interest. Which wasn't there, so they left it dead.

[Orvas Dren]

Tyranny is one of the most blatantly unfinished games I've ever seen

[Emphyrio]

Tyranny is one of the most blatantly unfinished games I've ever seen

not a problem if you just don't finish it