We have a Steam curator now. You should be following it. https://store.steampowered.com/curator/44994899-RPGHQ/
Chat client updated, if you have issues using chat press CTRL + SHIFT + R to force a hard refresh.

Baldur's Gate 3

For discussing role-playing video games, you know, the ones with combat.
Ignore Topic
User avatar
Oyster Sauce
Site Moderator
Posts: 11291
Joined: Jun 2, '23

Geolocation

Adventurer's Guild

Post by Oyster Sauce »

Vaako wrote: ↑ September 4th, 2025, 22:25
Trickster wrote: ↑ September 4th, 2025, 21:16
I'm done with this game. Really, delete it from my PC. This is the first game I've abandoned because of its characters and plot. The plot is superficial, devoid of any interesting conflict or dynamism, and seems like it was created by a redditor with a negative IQ. The characters are repulsive. That's it. Seriously. I just have no desire to travel on a campaign with these jerks who are literal self-inserts of woke morons. I am not a fan of homo-perversions; "polyamory," to me, is a mockery of true love and human relationships as a concept. I see nothing exciting, beautiful, or believable in this game. Just the fantasies of distorted, superficial people, deeply shallow and the complete opposite of what a world of sword and magic should be. But I abandoned the game not only because of that. It's also just poorly made. I started a new run and tried to act outside the game's rules, and it immediately started to break.

There's a scripted event where a Goblin kills the main character with a boulder, even though I had the cloak of invisibility beforehand and no sight checks occurred as I approached him. Then, before entering the ruined temple of Selune, I dismiss Shadowheart to go wherever she wants for not telling me she worships Shar; she leaves with the artifact, but the artifact is mentioned as if I have it during the conversation with the hobgoblin. If, after all that, you go to Withers, he won't be in the sarcophagus, but after the very first rest, he shows up in your camp without introducing himself. And Shadowheart, who supposedly left, is there with him. At that point, I snapped and deleted the game. This is not an RPG. It's a linear movie-like experience that lacks any actual cinematic quality.

The only things this piece of crap has going for it are the graphics and some of the music. But overall, it's terrible. I don't understand why this became popular. No, not even that. The very fact that this became popular is a death sentence for the genre. Zero out of ten.
You sure you installed the right game? I cant remember any goblin with a boulder which would insta kill you.
There's an Indiana Jones boulder trap in the gnoll cave. Somehow I've only ever approached it from behind on like 10/10 act 1s I've played so I have no idea what happens if you go the other way.
User avatar
Trickster
Posts: 955
Joined: Oct 5, '24
Gender: Watermelon

Geolocation

Adventurer's Guild

Post by Trickster »

Vaako wrote: ↑ September 4th, 2025, 22:25
I cant remember any goblin with a boulder which would insta kill you.
Image
Vaako wrote: ↑ September 4th, 2025, 22:25
any ruined selune temple in act1
https://forgottenrealms.fandom.com/wiki ... ed_Sanctum
User avatar
Vaako
Posts: 1543
Joined: Oct 17, '23

Geolocation

Post by Vaako »

Trickster wrote: ↑ September 4th, 2025, 23:07
Vaako wrote: ↑ September 4th, 2025, 22:25
I cant remember any goblin with a boulder which would insta kill you.
Image
Vaako wrote: ↑ September 4th, 2025, 22:25
any ruined selune temple in act1
https://forgottenrealms.fandom.com/wiki ... ed_Sanctum
Never managed to get killed by that. Usually one of the goblins dies before they can talk to me or I run through disguised as a drow. And yes I remember now that goblin stronghold was also a selune temple. With a hidden entrance to the underdark you missed the best part if you werent down there. :sad:
Last edited by Vaako on September 4th, 2025, 23:26, edited 1 time in total.
"I don't care what they tell you in College of Winterhold, Tiber Septim was a Redguard.”
User avatar
Vaako
Posts: 1543
Joined: Oct 17, '23

Geolocation

Post by Vaako »

Oyster Sauce wrote: ↑ September 4th, 2025, 22:54
Vaako wrote: ↑ September 4th, 2025, 22:25
Trickster wrote: ↑ September 4th, 2025, 21:16
I'm done with this game. Really, delete it from my PC. This is the first game I've abandoned because of its characters and plot. The plot is superficial, devoid of any interesting conflict or dynamism, and seems like it was created by a redditor with a negative IQ. The characters are repulsive. That's it. Seriously. I just have no desire to travel on a campaign with these jerks who are literal self-inserts of woke morons. I am not a fan of homo-perversions; "polyamory," to me, is a mockery of true love and human relationships as a concept. I see nothing exciting, beautiful, or believable in this game. Just the fantasies of distorted, superficial people, deeply shallow and the complete opposite of what a world of sword and magic should be. But I abandoned the game not only because of that. It's also just poorly made. I started a new run and tried to act outside the game's rules, and it immediately started to break.

There's a scripted event where a Goblin kills the main character with a boulder, even though I had the cloak of invisibility beforehand and no sight checks occurred as I approached him. Then, before entering the ruined temple of Selune, I dismiss Shadowheart to go wherever she wants for not telling me she worships Shar; she leaves with the artifact, but the artifact is mentioned as if I have it during the conversation with the hobgoblin. If, after all that, you go to Withers, he won't be in the sarcophagus, but after the very first rest, he shows up in your camp without introducing himself. And Shadowheart, who supposedly left, is there with him. At that point, I snapped and deleted the game. This is not an RPG. It's a linear movie-like experience that lacks any actual cinematic quality.

The only things this piece of crap has going for it are the graphics and some of the music. But overall, it's terrible. I don't understand why this became popular. No, not even that. The very fact that this became popular is a death sentence for the genre. Zero out of ten.
You sure you installed the right game? I cant remember any goblin with a boulder which would insta kill you.
There's an Indiana Jones boulder trap in the gnoll cave. Somehow I've only ever approached it from behind on like 10/10 act 1s I've played so I have no idea what happens if you go the other way.
Yeah that one with the gnolls I remember that one got me killed a few times when I tried to be stealthy and get the gnolls from behind and loot the barrels. :rip:
Last edited by Vaako on September 4th, 2025, 23:28, edited 1 time in total.
"I don't care what they tell you in College of Winterhold, Tiber Septim was a Redguard.”
User avatar
rusty_shackleford
Site Admin
Posts: 45450
Joined: Feb 2, '23
Gender: Watermelon

Geolocation

Adventurer's Guild

Post by rusty_shackleford »

I don't even remember a boulder but that seems quite odd, the game tended be good about those kind of things
Thank you for your attention to this matter!
Steam friend code: 40552640 https://steamcommunity.com/friends/add | email: [email protected]
Having trouble running an old Windows game?
Rusty's Stuff Collection
User avatar
MrTwinkls
Posts: 645
Joined: Mar 12, '24

Geolocation

Post by MrTwinkls »

This game is best described as broken or flawed. You can attach these adjectives to any game element and it will be correct except music maybe but still it's hard to best Kirill Pokrovsky's work. RIP.
User avatar
TheEmptyRoad
Posts: 384
Joined: Feb 29, '24

Geolocation

Adventurer's Guild

Post by TheEmptyRoad »

Trickster wrote: ↑ September 4th, 2025, 23:07
Vaako wrote: ↑ September 4th, 2025, 22:25
I cant remember any goblin with a boulder which would insta kill you.
Image
Vaako wrote: ↑ September 4th, 2025, 22:25
any ruined selune temple in act1
https://forgottenrealms.fandom.com/wiki ... ed_Sanctum
I've never seen that before. Wild.
Skyrim Belongs to the Nords.
Geek the Mage first.
There is no virtue in extending mercy to those who want you dead.
Justice will prevail, you say? But of course it will! Whoever wins this war becomes justice!
User avatar
Demonic Fate
Posts: 694
Joined: Feb 19, '25

Geolocation

Adventurer's Guild

Post by Demonic Fate »

Trickster wrote: ↑ September 4th, 2025, 23:07
Vaako wrote: ↑ September 4th, 2025, 22:25
I cant remember any goblin with a boulder which would insta kill you.
Image
Lmao. You deserved it for playing as a girl.
User avatar
logincrash
The Music Man
Posts: 6039
Joined: Sep 3, '23
Location: Niger

Geolocation

Adventurer's Guild

Post by logincrash »

The existence of Githyankee implies that there's such a thing as Githdixie.
"Oh, it all makes sense now, brother."
User avatar
swbgtoc
Posts: 161
Joined: Sep 6, '24

Geolocation

Post by swbgtoc »

Trickster wrote: ↑ September 4th, 2025, 21:16
I'm done with this game. Really, delete it from my PC. This is the first game I've abandoned because of its characters and plot. The plot is superficial, devoid of any interesting conflict or dynamism, and seems like it was created by a redditor with a negative IQ. The characters are repulsive. That's it. Seriously. I just have no desire to travel on a campaign with these jerks who are literal self-inserts of woke morons. I am not a fan of homo-perversions; "polyamory," to me, is a mockery of true love and human relationships as a concept. I see nothing exciting, beautiful, or believable in this game. Just the fantasies of distorted, superficial people, deeply shallow and the complete opposite of what a world of sword and magic should be. But I abandoned the game not only because of that. It's also just poorly made. I started a new run and tried to act outside the game's rules, and it immediately started to break.

There's a scripted event where a Goblin kills my character with a boulder, even though I had the cloak of invisibility (The Deathstalker Mantle) beforehand and no sight checks occurred as I approached him. Then, before entering the ruined temple of Selune, I dismiss Shadowheart to go wherever she wants for not telling me she worships Shar; she leaves with the artifact, but the artifact is mentioned as if I have it during the conversation with the hobgoblin. If, after all that, you go to Withers, he won't be in the sarcophagus, but after the very first rest, he shows up in your camp without introducing himself. And Shadowheart, who supposedly left, is there with him. At that point, I snapped and deleted the game. This is not an RPG. It's a linear movie-like experience that lacks any actual cinematic quality.

The only things this piece of crap has going for it are the graphics and some of the music. But overall, it's terrible. I don't understand why this became popular. No, not even that. The very fact that this became popular is a death sentence for the genre. Zero out of ten.
I uninstalled the game so I can't test the boulder thing but seeing your other issues I will assume the problem was between the chair and the keyboard.
You dismissed Shadowheart to your camp so she went to your camp and you were surprised to find her at your camp. :lol:
And you kicked her out because you were upset she kept her worship of the goddess of secrecy a secret. :roll:
I don't know why they didn't make a small introduction to Withers in case you missed him in the tomb, it's a small oversight but not a reason to ragequit.

Sure the characters are dogshit but the plot is perfectly fine, most old RPGs didn't do any better. Also you can ignore the characters, it shouldn't be the best option of an RPG I know but it's better than dealing with them. You can play with custom characters by launching a multiplayer campaign and four clients (and close the clients once you've created the characters) or use a mod. It's annoying you have to do this when this should have been the hirelings system but at least it's possible.
And seeing how angry you are at these soulless companions being player sexual (which is purely a meta decision to allow anyone to romance the character they like, it's not part of their personalities) shows where your interest really lies, go back to gooner VNs instead of playing RPGs. There isn't even polyamory in this game, the characters will break up if you **** someone else.
There simply is no game that both offer as much freedom to the player AND react accordingly other than the first act of BG3. (Act 3 is a mess and Act 2 is a lot smaller and more linear, but Act 1 makes up for it by being massive)

You spent so much time seething about the game before even playing it, you can't form a real opinion about it.
User avatar
Trickster
Posts: 955
Joined: Oct 5, '24
Gender: Watermelon

Geolocation

Adventurer's Guild

Post by Trickster »

swbgtoc wrote: ↑ September 16th, 2025, 17:55
Trickster wrote: ↑ September 4th, 2025, 21:16
I'm done with this game. Really, delete it from my PC. This is the first game I've abandoned because of its characters and plot. The plot is superficial, devoid of any interesting conflict or dynamism, and seems like it was created by a redditor with a negative IQ. The characters are repulsive. That's it. Seriously. I just have no desire to travel on a campaign with these jerks who are literal self-inserts of woke morons. I am not a fan of homo-perversions; "polyamory," to me, is a mockery of true love and human relationships as a concept. I see nothing exciting, beautiful, or believable in this game. Just the fantasies of distorted, superficial people, deeply shallow and the complete opposite of what a world of sword and magic should be. But I abandoned the game not only because of that. It's also just poorly made. I started a new run and tried to act outside the game's rules, and it immediately started to break.

There's a scripted event where a Goblin kills my character with a boulder, even though I had the cloak of invisibility (The Deathstalker Mantle) beforehand and no sight checks occurred as I approached him. Then, before entering the ruined temple of Selune, I dismiss Shadowheart to go wherever she wants for not telling me she worships Shar; she leaves with the artifact, but the artifact is mentioned as if I have it during the conversation with the hobgoblin. If, after all that, you go to Withers, he won't be in the sarcophagus, but after the very first rest, he shows up in your camp without introducing himself. And Shadowheart, who supposedly left, is there with him. At that point, I snapped and deleted the game. This is not an RPG. It's a linear movie-like experience that lacks any actual cinematic quality.

The only things this piece of crap has going for it are the graphics and some of the music. But overall, it's terrible. I don't understand why this became popular. No, not even that. The very fact that this became popular is a death sentence for the genre. Zero out of ten.
I uninstalled the game so I can't test the boulder thing but seeing your other issues I will assume the problem was between the chair and the keyboard.
You dismissed Shadowheart to your camp so she went to your camp and you were surprised to find her at your camp. :lol:
And you kicked her out because you were upset she kept her worship of the goddess of secrecy a secret. :roll:
I don't know why they didn't make a small introduction to Withers in case you missed him in the tomb, it's a small oversight but not a reason to ragequit.

Sure the characters are dogshit but the plot is perfectly fine, most old RPGs didn't do any better. Also you can ignore the characters, it shouldn't be the best option of an RPG I know but it's better than dealing with them. You can play with custom characters by launching a multiplayer campaign and four clients (and close the clients once you've created the characters) or use a mod. It's annoying you have to do this when this should have been the hirelings system but at least it's possible.
And seeing how angry you are at these soulless companions being player sexual (which is purely a meta decision to allow anyone to romance the character they like, it's not part of their personalities) shows where your interest really lies, go back to gooner VNs instead of playing RPGs. There isn't even polyamory in this game, the characters will break up if you **** someone else.
There simply is no game that both offer as much freedom to the player AND react accordingly other than the first act of BG3. (Act 3 is a mess and Act 2 is a lot smaller and more linear, but Act 1 makes up for it by being massive)

You spent so much time seething about the game before even playing it, you can't form a real opinion about it.
Word salad
User avatar
ArcaneLurker
Posts: 5671
Joined: Feb 6, '24

Geolocation

Post by ArcaneLurker »

Demonic Fate wrote: ↑ September 6th, 2025, 07:56
Trickster wrote: ↑ September 4th, 2025, 23:07
Vaako wrote: ↑ September 4th, 2025, 22:25
I cant remember any goblin with a boulder which would insta kill you.
Image
Lmao. You deserved it for playing as a girl.
Could have a **** for all you know
I apologize if my responses were not relevant to your needs. As an AI language model, I do not have personal beliefs or opinions, and I only provide responses based on the information provided to me.
User avatar
Unhelpful Contrarian
Posts: 3187
Joined: Aug 24, '24

Geolocation

Post by Unhelpful Contrarian »

swbgtoc wrote: ↑ September 16th, 2025, 17:55
Trickster wrote: ↑ September 4th, 2025, 21:16
I'm done with this game. Really, delete it from my PC. This is the first game I've abandoned because of its characters and plot. The plot is superficial, devoid of any interesting conflict or dynamism, and seems like it was created by a redditor with a negative IQ. The characters are repulsive. That's it. Seriously. I just have no desire to travel on a campaign with these jerks who are literal self-inserts of woke morons. I am not a fan of homo-perversions; "polyamory," to me, is a mockery of true love and human relationships as a concept. I see nothing exciting, beautiful, or believable in this game. Just the fantasies of distorted, superficial people, deeply shallow and the complete opposite of what a world of sword and magic should be. But I abandoned the game not only because of that. It's also just poorly made. I started a new run and tried to act outside the game's rules, and it immediately started to break.

There's a scripted event where a Goblin kills my character with a boulder, even though I had the cloak of invisibility (The Deathstalker Mantle) beforehand and no sight checks occurred as I approached him. Then, before entering the ruined temple of Selune, I dismiss Shadowheart to go wherever she wants for not telling me she worships Shar; she leaves with the artifact, but the artifact is mentioned as if I have it during the conversation with the hobgoblin. If, after all that, you go to Withers, he won't be in the sarcophagus, but after the very first rest, he shows up in your camp without introducing himself. And Shadowheart, who supposedly left, is there with him. At that point, I snapped and deleted the game. This is not an RPG. It's a linear movie-like experience that lacks any actual cinematic quality.

The only things this piece of crap has going for it are the graphics and some of the music. But overall, it's terrible. I don't understand why this became popular. No, not even that. The very fact that this became popular is a death sentence for the genre. Zero out of ten.
I uninstalled the game so I can't test the boulder thing but seeing your other issues I will assume the problem was between the chair and the keyboard.
You dismissed Shadowheart to your camp so she went to your camp and you were surprised to find her at your camp. :lol:
And you kicked her out because you were upset she kept her worship of the goddess of secrecy a secret. :roll:
I don't know why they didn't make a small introduction to Withers in case you missed him in the tomb, it's a small oversight but not a reason to ragequit.

Sure the characters are dogshit but the plot is perfectly fine, most old RPGs didn't do any better. Also you can ignore the characters, it shouldn't be the best option of an RPG I know but it's better than dealing with them. You can play with custom characters by launching a multiplayer campaign and four clients (and close the clients once you've created the characters) or use a mod. It's annoying you have to do this when this should have been the hirelings system but at least it's possible.
And seeing how angry you are at these soulless companions being player sexual (which is purely a meta decision to allow anyone to romance the character they like, it's not part of their personalities) shows where your interest really lies, go back to gooner VNs instead of playing RPGs. There isn't even polyamory in this game, the characters will break up if you **** someone else.
There simply is no game that both offer as much freedom to the player AND react accordingly other than the first act of BG3. (Act 3 is a mess and Act 2 is a lot smaller and more linear, but Act 1 makes up for it by being massive)

You spent so much time seething about the game before even playing it, you can't form a real opinion about it.
His point may be slightly hyperbolic but the criticisms are 100% spot on. It’s deeply black pilling seeing your type of comments dominate the general sentiment on BG3 because I know for a fact that RPG studios will take the wrong lessons.
User avatar
swbgtoc
Posts: 161
Joined: Sep 6, '24

Geolocation

Post by swbgtoc »

Unhelpful Contrarian wrote: ↑ September 20th, 2025, 02:10
swbgtoc wrote: ↑ September 16th, 2025, 17:55
Trickster wrote: ↑ September 4th, 2025, 21:16
I'm done with this game. Really, delete it from my PC. This is the first game I've abandoned because of its characters and plot. The plot is superficial, devoid of any interesting conflict or dynamism, and seems like it was created by a redditor with a negative IQ. The characters are repulsive. That's it. Seriously. I just have no desire to travel on a campaign with these jerks who are literal self-inserts of woke morons. I am not a fan of homo-perversions; "polyamory," to me, is a mockery of true love and human relationships as a concept. I see nothing exciting, beautiful, or believable in this game. Just the fantasies of distorted, superficial people, deeply shallow and the complete opposite of what a world of sword and magic should be. But I abandoned the game not only because of that. It's also just poorly made. I started a new run and tried to act outside the game's rules, and it immediately started to break.

There's a scripted event where a Goblin kills my character with a boulder, even though I had the cloak of invisibility (The Deathstalker Mantle) beforehand and no sight checks occurred as I approached him. Then, before entering the ruined temple of Selune, I dismiss Shadowheart to go wherever she wants for not telling me she worships Shar; she leaves with the artifact, but the artifact is mentioned as if I have it during the conversation with the hobgoblin. If, after all that, you go to Withers, he won't be in the sarcophagus, but after the very first rest, he shows up in your camp without introducing himself. And Shadowheart, who supposedly left, is there with him. At that point, I snapped and deleted the game. This is not an RPG. It's a linear movie-like experience that lacks any actual cinematic quality.

The only things this piece of crap has going for it are the graphics and some of the music. But overall, it's terrible. I don't understand why this became popular. No, not even that. The very fact that this became popular is a death sentence for the genre. Zero out of ten.
I uninstalled the game so I can't test the boulder thing but seeing your other issues I will assume the problem was between the chair and the keyboard.
You dismissed Shadowheart to your camp so she went to your camp and you were surprised to find her at your camp. :lol:
And you kicked her out because you were upset she kept her worship of the goddess of secrecy a secret. :roll:
I don't know why they didn't make a small introduction to Withers in case you missed him in the tomb, it's a small oversight but not a reason to ragequit.

Sure the characters are dogshit but the plot is perfectly fine, most old RPGs didn't do any better. Also you can ignore the characters, it shouldn't be the best option of an RPG I know but it's better than dealing with them. You can play with custom characters by launching a multiplayer campaign and four clients (and close the clients once you've created the characters) or use a mod. It's annoying you have to do this when this should have been the hirelings system but at least it's possible.
And seeing how angry you are at these soulless companions being player sexual (which is purely a meta decision to allow anyone to romance the character they like, it's not part of their personalities) shows where your interest really lies, go back to gooner VNs instead of playing RPGs. There isn't even polyamory in this game, the characters will break up if you **** someone else.
There simply is no game that both offer as much freedom to the player AND react accordingly other than the first act of BG3. (Act 3 is a mess and Act 2 is a lot smaller and more linear, but Act 1 makes up for it by being massive)

You spent so much time seething about the game before even playing it, you can't form a real opinion about it.
His point may be slightly hyperbolic but the criticisms are 100% spot on. It’s deeply black pilling seeing your type of comments dominate the general sentiment on BG3 because I know for a fact that RPG studios will take the wrong lessons.
They're not 100% spot on at all. He just called the story and characters reddit. Even if I agree at least for the characters there is no lesson to be learned.
Then he got what appears to be a bug (the boulder), an oversight (Withers) and something working as intended he didn't understand (dismissing a party member). And these aren't massive problems. They put a lot of work in Act 1 for it to be a semi-open world that evolves and reacts appropriately to your actions.
Just before playing BG3 I played IWD on the junior adventurer guild thread and that game was much more linear and didn't leave much role playing options in comparison. I'll try playing BG1 and 2 later to compare (I already played BG1 a long time ago but never finished it)
User avatar
rusty_shackleford
Site Admin
Posts: 45450
Joined: Feb 2, '23
Gender: Watermelon

Geolocation

Adventurer's Guild

Post by rusty_shackleford »

swbgtoc wrote: ↑ September 22nd, 2025, 10:40
Unhelpful Contrarian wrote: ↑ September 20th, 2025, 02:10
swbgtoc wrote: ↑ September 16th, 2025, 17:55


I uninstalled the game so I can't test the boulder thing but seeing your other issues I will assume the problem was between the chair and the keyboard.
You dismissed Shadowheart to your camp so she went to your camp and you were surprised to find her at your camp. :lol:
And you kicked her out because you were upset she kept her worship of the goddess of secrecy a secret. :roll:
I don't know why they didn't make a small introduction to Withers in case you missed him in the tomb, it's a small oversight but not a reason to ragequit.

Sure the characters are dogshit but the plot is perfectly fine, most old RPGs didn't do any better. Also you can ignore the characters, it shouldn't be the best option of an RPG I know but it's better than dealing with them. You can play with custom characters by launching a multiplayer campaign and four clients (and close the clients once you've created the characters) or use a mod. It's annoying you have to do this when this should have been the hirelings system but at least it's possible.
And seeing how angry you are at these soulless companions being player sexual (which is purely a meta decision to allow anyone to romance the character they like, it's not part of their personalities) shows where your interest really lies, go back to gooner VNs instead of playing RPGs. There isn't even polyamory in this game, the characters will break up if you **** someone else.
There simply is no game that both offer as much freedom to the player AND react accordingly other than the first act of BG3. (Act 3 is a mess and Act 2 is a lot smaller and more linear, but Act 1 makes up for it by being massive)

You spent so much time seething about the game before even playing it, you can't form a real opinion about it.
His point may be slightly hyperbolic but the criticisms are 100% spot on. It’s deeply black pilling seeing your type of comments dominate the general sentiment on BG3 because I know for a fact that RPG studios will take the wrong lessons.
They're not 100% spot on at all. He just called the story and characters reddit. Even if I agree at least for the characters there is no lesson to be learned.
Then he got what appears to be a bug (the boulder), an oversight (Withers) and something working as intended he didn't understand (dismissing a party member). And these aren't massive problems. They put a lot of work in Act 1 for it to be a semi-open world that evolves and reacts appropriately to your actions.
Just before playing BG3 I played IWD on the junior adventurer guild thread and that game was much more linear and didn't leave much role playing options in comparison. I'll try playing BG1 and 2 later to compare (I already played BG1 a long time ago but never finished it)
Have you played larian's other games, or Fallout?
Thank you for your attention to this matter!
Steam friend code: 40552640 https://steamcommunity.com/friends/add | email: [email protected]
Having trouble running an old Windows game?
Rusty's Stuff Collection
User avatar
swbgtoc
Posts: 161
Joined: Sep 6, '24

Geolocation

Post by swbgtoc »

rusty_shackleford wrote: ↑ September 22nd, 2025, 10:54
swbgtoc wrote: ↑ September 22nd, 2025, 10:40
Unhelpful Contrarian wrote: ↑ September 20th, 2025, 02:10


His point may be slightly hyperbolic but the criticisms are 100% spot on. It’s deeply black pilling seeing your type of comments dominate the general sentiment on BG3 because I know for a fact that RPG studios will take the wrong lessons.
They're not 100% spot on at all. He just called the story and characters reddit. Even if I agree at least for the characters there is no lesson to be learned.
Then he got what appears to be a bug (the boulder), an oversight (Withers) and something working as intended he didn't understand (dismissing a party member). And these aren't massive problems. They put a lot of work in Act 1 for it to be a semi-open world that evolves and reacts appropriately to your actions.
Just before playing BG3 I played IWD on the junior adventurer guild thread and that game was much more linear and didn't leave much role playing options in comparison. I'll try playing BG1 and 2 later to compare (I already played BG1 a long time ago but never finished it)
Have you played larian's other games, or Fallout?
I've played DOS2 which I preferred over BG3 and Fallout 4 that I didn't like then I tried Fallout 1 but it was too hard I got filtered
User avatar
rusty_shackleford
Site Admin
Posts: 45450
Joined: Feb 2, '23
Gender: Watermelon

Geolocation

Adventurer's Guild

Post by rusty_shackleford »

swbgtoc wrote: ↑ September 22nd, 2025, 11:38
rusty_shackleford wrote: ↑ September 22nd, 2025, 10:54
swbgtoc wrote: ↑ September 22nd, 2025, 10:40


They're not 100% spot on at all. He just called the story and characters reddit. Even if I agree at least for the characters there is no lesson to be learned.
Then he got what appears to be a bug (the boulder), an oversight (Withers) and something working as intended he didn't understand (dismissing a party member). And these aren't massive problems. They put a lot of work in Act 1 for it to be a semi-open world that evolves and reacts appropriately to your actions.
Just before playing BG3 I played IWD on the junior adventurer guild thread and that game was much more linear and didn't leave much role playing options in comparison. I'll try playing BG1 and 2 later to compare (I already played BG1 a long time ago but never finished it)
Have you played larian's other games, or Fallout?
I've played DOS2 which I preferred over BG3 and Fallout 4 that I didn't like then I tried Fallout 1 but it was too hard I got filtered
:)
viewtopic.php?t=3524-junior-adventurer- ... h-atom-rpg
Thank you for your attention to this matter!
Steam friend code: 40552640 https://steamcommunity.com/friends/add | email: [email protected]
Having trouble running an old Windows game?
Rusty's Stuff Collection
User avatar
swbgtoc
Posts: 161
Joined: Sep 6, '24

Geolocation

Post by swbgtoc »

rusty_shackleford wrote: ↑ September 22nd, 2025, 11:39
swbgtoc wrote: ↑ September 22nd, 2025, 11:38
rusty_shackleford wrote: ↑ September 22nd, 2025, 10:54


Have you played larian's other games, or Fallout?
I've played DOS2 which I preferred over BG3 and Fallout 4 that I didn't like then I tried Fallout 1 but it was too hard I got filtered
:)
viewtopic.php?t=3524-junior-adventurer- ... h-atom-rpg
Can I play it with one hand? I broke my left arm yesterday
Also I already played Arcanum it was great
User avatar
rusty_shackleford
Site Admin
Posts: 45450
Joined: Feb 2, '23
Gender: Watermelon

Geolocation

Adventurer's Guild

Post by rusty_shackleford »

swbgtoc wrote: ↑ September 22nd, 2025, 11:42
Can I play it with one hand?
Think so from what I can remember, should be able to play entirely with the mouse.
swbgtoc wrote: ↑ September 22nd, 2025, 11:42
I broke my left arm yesterday
:(
multiple recent arm breaks around here
Thank you for your attention to this matter!
Steam friend code: 40552640 https://steamcommunity.com/friends/add | email: [email protected]
Having trouble running an old Windows game?
Rusty's Stuff Collection
User avatar
gerey
Turtle
Turtle
Posts: 3200
Joined: Feb 2, '23

Geolocation

Adventurer's Guild

Post by gerey »

This mod might be of interest to some:



Mod author claims to restore over 100 scenes from EA that were cut.
Last edited by gerey on September 25th, 2025, 13:12, edited 1 time in total.
User avatar
rusty_shackleford
Site Admin
Posts: 45450
Joined: Feb 2, '23
Gender: Watermelon

Geolocation

Adventurer's Guild

Post by rusty_shackleford »

People who didn't play the EA have no idea, the game went on a completely different path from what we were shown originally.
Thank you for your attention to this matter!
Steam friend code: 40552640 https://steamcommunity.com/friends/add | email: [email protected]
Having trouble running an old Windows game?
Rusty's Stuff Collection
User avatar
MrTwinkls
Posts: 645
Joined: Mar 12, '24

Geolocation

Post by MrTwinkls »

rusty_shackleford wrote: ↑ September 25th, 2025, 13:15
People who didn't play the EA have no idea, the game went on a completely different path from what we were shown originally.
I didn't play the EA so don't know how it was before the release but the game felt magnitudes more gutted than even earlier Obsidian games.
User avatar
Mikeal
Posts: 47
Joined: Feb 16, '23

Geolocation

Post by Mikeal »

So how original vision looked an what was gutted?
User avatar
Cretin
Posts: 36
Joined: Sep 18, '23

Geolocation

Post by Cretin »

rusty_shackleford wrote: July 19th, 2025, 06:29
Try to find your favorite comment


Image
Image
Most people have absolutely no idea what the demographics of people who play RPGs is.

The entire game is porn-brained, not romantic in either the modern or classical sense, but as it is Laezel is the best romance in the game and I will die on that hill. If they made laezel look like this:

Image
Image
Image


instead of a frogwoman, shart would be some weird ****** ****** who is also just a moody **** most of the time. Laezel's romance is the only one that has an actual arc and significant character development. Then theres the fact that laezel stomps the **** out of everything in the game while shart is just a mediocre healbot unless you respec.

Also laezel is a fascist, clearly, shes the choice for any self-respecting racist bodybuilder.

User avatar
CheesusCrust
Posts: 604
Joined: Nov 6, '23
Location: Nobere's two dads' bedroom

Geolocation

Post by CheesusCrust »

CheesusCrust wrote: ↑ June 24th, 2025, 19:53
BLofbr wrote: ↑ June 24th, 2025, 18:59
Something was off i agree.

Looks like she is in Iran? lmao dunno if true but i check her website.


like @Trickster said, she's dumb as ****. no matter what ******* happens in your ******* home, don't share your location online. meanwhile this **** on her Patreon:
Image
Image
hey my gay *******, check this out

Image
User avatar
rusty_shackleford
Site Admin
Posts: 45450
Joined: Feb 2, '23
Gender: Watermelon

Geolocation

Adventurer's Guild

Post by rusty_shackleford »

CheesusCrust wrote: ↑ October 5th, 2025, 17:03
CheesusCrust wrote: ↑ June 24th, 2025, 19:53
BLofbr wrote: ↑ June 24th, 2025, 18:59
Something was off i agree.

Looks like she is in Iran? lmao dunno if true but i check her website.


like @Trickster said, she's dumb as ****. no matter what ******* happens in your ******* home, don't share your location online. meanwhile this **** on her Patreon:
Image
Image
hey my gay *******, check this out

Image
wow that's crazy
buy hq platinum
Thank you for your attention to this matter!
Steam friend code: 40552640 https://steamcommunity.com/friends/add | email: [email protected]
Having trouble running an old Windows game?
Rusty's Stuff Collection
User avatar
Barntar who Plows
Posts: 40
Joined: Nov 2, '25
Location: Hell, MI

Geolocation

Post by Barntar who Plows »

Much like 2077, I have no idea how anyone who isn't a niggercattle can enjoy this game. Is there something I'm missing?
Send me writing ideas, need the practice. :wizard:
User avatar
Tweed
Turtle
Turtle
Posts: 6837
Joined: Feb 2, '23

Geolocation

Adventurer's Guild

Post by Tweed »

Barntar who Plows wrote: ↑ November 11th, 2025, 05:05
Much like 2077, I have no idea how anyone who isn't a niggercattle can enjoy this game. Is there something I'm missing?
Incredibly low standards, desperation, and a porn addiction.
User avatar
Oyster Sauce
Site Moderator
Posts: 11291
Joined: Jun 2, '23

Geolocation

Adventurer's Guild

Post by Oyster Sauce »

Tweed wrote: ↑ November 11th, 2025, 06:48
Barntar who Plows wrote: ↑ November 11th, 2025, 05:05
Much like 2077, I have no idea how anyone who isn't a niggercattle can enjoy this game. Is there something I'm missing?
Incredibly low standards, desperation, and a porn addiction.
Tweed wrote: ↑ November 8th, 2025, 02:57
If for any reason we receive a key offer for A Kobold Story: Trenchcoat Adventurer I get it, no exceptions.
User avatar
Tweed
Turtle
Turtle
Posts: 6837
Joined: Feb 2, '23

Geolocation

Adventurer's Guild

Post by Tweed »

Oyster Sauce wrote: ↑ November 11th, 2025, 07:19
Tweed wrote: ↑ November 11th, 2025, 06:48
Barntar who Plows wrote: ↑ November 11th, 2025, 05:05
Much like 2077, I have no idea how anyone who isn't a niggercattle can enjoy this game. Is there something I'm missing?
Incredibly low standards, desperation, and a porn addiction.
Tweed wrote: ↑ November 8th, 2025, 02:57
If for any reason we receive a key offer for A Kobold Story: Trenchcoat Adventurer I get it, no exceptions.