"Bouncing" pixel art looks ******* terrible

[rusty_shackleford]

Who do I have to bully to put an end to this?

[GhostCow]

Personally I think all pixel art looks terrible and should be left to the confines of history.

inb4 someone posts a bunch of screenshots from their favorite 2d era console. Sorry, you're not going to convince me.

[rusty_shackleford]

This looks like absolute trash. People do not bob in place like this.


The games they're trying to be like never looked like this.


The characters are not bouncing around like they have untreated ADHD.

[KnightoftheWind]

Personally I think all pixel art looks terrible and should be left to the confines of history.

inb4 someone posts a bunch of screenshots from their favorite 2d era console. Sorry, you're not going to convince me.

Typical Zoomer. Say what you will about indie game tripe, but the era of pixel art ended far too early. It was just reaching it's prime with some Saturn/PS1 games, not to mention some NeoGeo heavy-hitters like Metal Slug.

[GhostCow]

Typical Zoomer.

I'm 39 you dumbfuck. Metal Slug looks good for it's era, but it's an art style that we had to use because of technical limitations. Not because it looked good.

This is what 2d art should look like in 2023. There is no excuse for pixelshit of any kind.


Shantae and the Seven Sirens is bouncy and looks good because it's not pixelshit.

[WhiteShark]

This is what 2d art should look like in 2023. There is no excuse for pixelshit of any kind.

Shantae looks great as always but that Sonic screenshot looks awful. I hope that's a mockup and not from an actual game.

Anyway, bouncing sprites are neat when they aren't overdone:

[KnightoftheWind]

Typical Zoomer.

I'm 39 you dumbfuck. Metal Slug looks good for it's era, but it's an art style that we had to use because of technical limitations. Not because it looked good.

This is what 2d art should look like in 2023. There is no excuse for pixelshit of any kind.


Shantae and the Seven Sirens is bouncy and looks good because it's not pixelshit.

Man your tastes really suck ***. You're saying you prefer 2D Flash/Newgrounds style animation over quality sprite work?.

[Klerik]

[GhostCow]

Shantae looks great as always but that Sonic screenshot looks awful. I hope that's a mockup and not from an actual game.

It's an old mockup from many years ago. I always thought it looked great and I had to google my *** off to find it. There is however an actual Sonic 2 HD remake being made by fans and it looks like this:

I don't know how anyone could think the left looks better than the right.

Man your tastes really suck ***. You're saying you prefer 2D Flash/Newgrounds style animation over quality sprite work?.

I dunno man, I never really played flash games because they are **** so it's hard for me to say. I think the only one I ever played was Dragonfable and it had pretty bad looking animation and I wasn't big on the art style they used. I don't think flash games are a fair comparison.

I hate pixels with a passion. I would be willing to spend like $10k if it would get me a 16k monitor and a video card that can drive it at high fps so I never have to see another pixel again.

[WhiteShark]

I don't know how anyone could think the left looks better than the right.

Right looks really flat and dull. Left has way more vivid colors: compare the gems in the totem pole, the contrast of the water to the clouds, the shadow below the turf, etc. I'm not a pixel supremacist but in this particular case the original is way, way better.

[maidenhaver]

Depends how far from the screen my fat *** is sitting.

[GhostCow]

Right looks really flat and dull.

Really weird thing to say when the right side has shading to give it depth and the left doesn't.

Left has way more vivid colors: compare the gems in the totem pole, the contrast of the water to the clouds, the shadow below the turf, etc.

We'll just have to disagree on the colors I guess. I think they look fine in either version, although the gem you pointed out is another thing I find a little weird. I'm not really a fan of that pukey neon green color. That color would probably signal something you should stay away from in nature.

[BosanskiSeljak]

Personally I think all pixel art looks terrible and should be left to the confines of history.

Agreed. When I see it nowadays I know its some RPGMaker trash or some wannabe JRPG indie garbage that a bunch of geeks suck off

[Klerik]

Maybe one day I'll have enough money that someone might like me a little bit.

[Tweed]

It's an old mockup from many years ago. I always thought it looked great and I had to google my *** off to find it. There is however an actual Sonic 2 HD remake being made by fans and it looks like this:

I don't know how anyone could think the left looks better than the right.

I hate pixels with a passion. I would be willing to spend like $10k if it would get me a 16k monitor and a video card that can drive it at high fps so I never have to see another pixel again.

Absolutely soulless.

[Klerik]

Having a soul is overrated. Dollar bills is where it's at.

[rusty_shackleford]

The bouncing animations remind me of Adam Sessler tweaking.

[Klerik]

[Acrux]

How long ago did this start? Here's a clip of designers talking about doing exactly this:

[rusty_shackleford]

How long ago did this start? Here's a clip of designers talking about doing exactly this:

[media]https://youtube.com/clip/UgkxELnv6dJCnC ... UStatvXTIb[/media]

Subtle breathing can be fine. The problem is that it tends to look bad on pixel art, and that's not what these characters are even doing. They're just bouncing in place.

[Klerik]

The problem is that bullying them will just make designers make sure they bounce even harder and more annoyingly because someone is getting off on it.

[WhiteShark]

Really weird thing to say when the right side has shading to give it depth and the left doesn't.

Genuine question: do you not see the shading in the left one? It's there and more distinctive than the one on the right to my eyes.

[Tweed]

[General Reign]

I tell you what pixel art I did not like...Blasphemous. It almost seems like too many frames of animation if that makes sense.

[GhostCow]

Really weird thing to say when the right side has shading to give it depth and the left doesn't.

Genuine question: do you not see the shading in the left one? It's there and more distinctive than the one on the right to my eyes.

I can see a little bit on Tails' tail but that's it. I have to look hard to see it since everything is made out of so few pixels. I also see a couple of shadows, which isn't the same thing.

I'm now starting to question if people who like pixelshit are filling in the gaps with their imagination instead of actually seeing what the art looks like.

[J1M]

Who do I have to bully to put an end to this?

A majority of what you see is just imitating other products for the sake of imitating.

As for why this happened, I would say it's probably a bandaid applied to address problems caused by poor art direction. It is very common in games today to see no discernible difference in contrast or lighting between interactive and background elements. Giving sprites a perpetual seizure solves the readability issue.

[Segata]

Image
I don't know how anyone could think the left looks better than the right.

People played left on a CRT, so it didn't look like that.

Anyways, this thread is about animations. And this is the right kind of bouncing:

[KnightoftheWind]

Image
I don't know how anyone could think the left looks better than the right.

People played left on a CRT, so it didn't look like that.

Anyways, this thread is about animations. And this is the right kind of bouncing:

Ah the good old days of gaming...

[Klerik]

[madbringer]

Personally I think all pixel art looks terrible and should be left to the confines of history.

inb4 someone posts a bunch of screenshots from their favorite 2d era console. Sorry, you're not going to convince me.

Personally, I like pixel art just purely for aesthetics, but it has been grossly abused and overused by lazy indie dev ***** to the point I can see why people get sick of it. ****** pixel art or unity model reskins, pick your poison.