RPG Ranking Thread

[Jordy]

Hidden Content

This board requires you to be registered and logged-in to view hidden content.

Will be doing so this eve.

[Hauberk]

I'd encourage others, especially if they fix where I went wrong.

I don't think you went wrong. This list covers a broader spectrum than the one I'm making so it figures that the results will (probably) be a bit different. It's interesting to note that so many of us like Morrowind, for example.

[rusty_shackleford]

@Jordy I think this is a good thread, shows the diverse range of opinions on a singular genre we have.

[Jordy]

Updated.

[rusty_shackleford]

1. ATOM RPG
2. Chronicles of Myrtana: Archolos
3. Fallout 2
4. Divinity II: The Dragon Knight Saga
5. Wizardry 8

@Jordy I've changed my #1 from "ATOM RPG + Trudograd" to "ATOM RPG", so that you can merge the existing ATOM RPG with it. That would remove "ATOM RPG + Trudograd" and bump "ATOM RPG" to 6 points.

[Jordy]

1. ATOM RPG
2. Chronicles of Myrtana: Archolos
3. Fallout 2
4. Divinity II: The Dragon Knight Saga
5. Wizardry 8

@Jordy I've changed my #1 from "ATOM RPG + Trudograd" to "ATOM RPG", so that you can merge the existing ATOM RPG with it. That would remove "ATOM RPG + Trudograd" and bump "ATOM RPG" to 6 points.

Alrighty - I'll quickly change that.

Edit: Done

[Gastrick]

Meanwhile, the new RPGCodex top RPGs list:

[1998]

Thought it would rank higher tbh

[Schizoid1488]

Meanwhile, the new RPGCodex top RPGs list:

Codex is an aids ridden shithole, honestly needs to be killed off at this point. 70% of posters there would be better off at Resetera, while 30% would be better of at the 'HQ. I am happy that more people are recognizing how full of **** every ****** there is, the meme vatnik crpg forums are memeing on their newest rpg ranking list and using it as an example of total decline and cognitive impairment, while the 'dex ****** desperately try to convince themselves they are still a prestigious forum that crpg devs and enthusiasts respect and care about. Grim.

[Hauberk]

If that shithole ever goes down, we need to stop accepting new members for a few years or have a "patron system" in place where new people need to be vouched for to be accepted, preferably so that who vouched for who is visible.

Not a joke.

[Mortmal]

1) Baldur's gate 3
2) Fallout 2
3) Baldur's gate 2
4) Ultima 7
5) Dungeon master

And really 5 is not enough , i could also put easily 5 more titles.

[BosanskiSeljak]

u have to be gay and fat pedo *** lover [that worked on it], to think fallout 1 is better than fallout 2

Love the projection.

Only gay and fat pedo **** prefer a themepark of lulz and *** **** over a grounded, consistent adventure through a post apocalyptic world.

[rusty_shackleford]

fallout 1 isn't an adventure, it's a 5 minute walk

[Tweed]

At least KCD and Underrail got bumped up on the Codex list, but a lot of things fell of completely.

[aweigh]

Meanwhile, the new RPGCodex top RPGs list:

Codex is an aids ridden shithole, honestly needs to be killed off at this point. 70% of posters there would be better off at Resetera, while 30% would be better of at the 'HQ. I am happy that more people are recognizing how full of **** every ****** there is, the meme vatnik crpg forums are memeing on their newest rpg ranking list and using it as an example of total decline and cognitive impairment, while the 'dex ****** desperately try to convince themselves they are still a prestigious forum that crpg devs and enthusiasts respect and care about. Grim.

sometimes i hate codex so much it chokes me up, it's almost unbearable

[Red7]

u have to be gay and fat pedo *** lover [that worked on it], to think fallout 1 is better than fallout 2

Love the projection.

Only gay and fat pedo **** prefer a themepark of lulz and *** **** over a grounded, consistent adventure through a post apocalyptic world.

this how he grabs 6 year old boy butt cheeks

[Red7]

Meanwhile, the new RPGCodex top RPGs list:

Codex is an aids ridden shithole, honestly needs to be killed off at this point. 70% of posters there would be better off at Resetera, while 30% would be better of at the 'HQ. I am happy that more people are recognizing how full of **** every ****** there is, the meme vatnik crpg forums are memeing on their newest rpg ranking list and using it as an example of total decline and cognitive impairment, while the 'dex ****** desperately try to convince themselves they are still a prestigious forum that crpg devs and enthusiasts respect and care about. Grim.

sometimes i hate codex so much it chokes me up, it's almost unbearable

arent kukdex servers in england? that would be easy target these days

i got idea.
somebody hack mods and du accounts and put some anti woke **** narrative, report to goverment, bam 12 years in prison

[maidenhaver]

Meanwhile, the new RPGCodex top RPGs list:

A good 30 of those games aren't rpgs.

[DDC]

1. Xenogears
2. Xenogears
3. Xenogears
4. Xenogears
5. Xenogears

That's 15 points for xenogears, moving it to #4 overall

[Faceless_Sentinel]

u have to be gay and fat pedo *** lover [that worked on it], to think fallout 1 is better than fallout 2

Love the projection.

Only gay and fat pedo **** prefer a themepark of lulz and *** **** over a grounded, consistent adventure through a post apocalyptic world.

this how he grabs 6 year old boy butt cheeks

I would rather you comment on this part of the argument: "Fallout 2 is themepark of lulz and *** ****".

[Red7]

Love the projection.

Only gay and fat pedo **** prefer a themepark of lulz and *** **** over a grounded, consistent adventure through a post apocalyptic world.

this how he grabs 6 year old boy butt cheeks

I would rather you comment on this part of the argument: "Fallout 2 is themepark of lulz and *** ****".

only after ending. before ending ******** goofy events are not triggering and the goofy **** that does occurs its acceptable to me mostly.
fallout1 does not even have vagina u can pimp and has time limit its absolute joke.

in fallout 2 i can **** crime boss wife, then his daughter then his wife again then kill him in front of his wife and daughter then reptedly **** his wife; better game
ideally u would have threesomes with daughter and her mother after killing her daddy, and make little **** call u daddy for heck of it, but f2 lacking on slavery aspect. still better than f1.

[Irenaeus]

Fallout 2 is still great despite the inconsistencies in tone and theme with the anachronisms, comedy and the worse villains. Or maybe it's nostalgia talking.

[Jordy]

1) Baldur's gate 3
2) Fallout 2
3) Baldur's gate 2
4) Ultima 7
5) Dungeon master

And really 5 is not enough , i could also put easily 5 more titles.

Feel free to create a similar thread for people's top 10.

[Jordy]

Updated.

[Element]

Meanwhile, the new RPGCodex top RPGs list:

they can say the same about DAO on here

[rusty_shackleford]

Meanwhile, the new RPGCodex top RPGs list:

they can say the same about DAO on here

DAO is an RPG tho?

[Jordy]

Meanwhile, the new RPGCodex top RPGs list:

they can say the same about DAO on here

Who cares what they say?

[pol_345polex]

Baldur's Gate II
Dragon Age: Origin
Baldur's Gate
Pillars of Eternity
Atom RPG: Trudograd

[Jordy]

@rusty_shackleford Does this mean you will want to change yours back now?

[Jordy]

Updated.