We have a Steam curator now. You should be following it. https://store.steampowered.com/curator/44994899-RPGHQ/
Chat client updated, if you have issues using chat press CTRL + SHIFT + R to force a hard refresh.

Top 10 bosses of the 2020s

No RPG elements? It probably goes here!
Ignore Topic
User avatar
Vlajdimir Ermenović
Posts: 647
Joined: Apr 18, '23
Location: a country
Gender: Lemon

Geolocation

Top 10 bosses of the 2020s

Post by Vlajdimir Ermenović »

copy-pasted from my substack
Dishonourable Mentions: Malenia, Blade of Miquella and Simon
Elden Ring (2022.) and Clair Obscur: Expedition 33 (2025.)
Image
Image


In Croatia, which is where I’m from, we have this concept named ‘‘preseravanje’’ (lit. over-********), which is overdoing something for the sake of appearing a certain way, but ending up making it stupid. That is the best word to describe these two bosses. They’re both their game’s respective superbosses, meaning they’re optional and meant to be exceptionally difficult, but in my opinion, both are poorly designed and go for a level of difficulty neither game’s combat system is equipped to handle.

Well, Malenia almost isn’t. Her moveset is mostly okay. Easy to understand, but hard to dodge, as it should be. But there is one attack, named the Waterfowl Dance, which requires either dumb luck or cheat code-level esoteric techniques to dodge. Simon, on the other hand, is just excessively long and punishing, requiring hundreds upon hundreds of perfectly timed parries to take down. You may handle one or two turns well enough, but considering his enormous health bar, you’ll eventually get bored and slip up. After getting wiped out for the 500th time because you missed one milisecond on attack 982 of 3874, you’ll decide the juice just isn’t worth the squeeze.

I wouldn’t rag on it, but I suspect the reason they are this way was to pander to these git gud kids who think hard is automatically good. Elden Ring and Clair Obscur are both good games, but considering the culture that exists around games like this, it wouldn’t surprise me. Either way, both of these games can and indeed did do better, so seeing them seemingly stoop to that kind of philistinism is offputting.


#10. - Prince Dion/Bahamut
Final Fantasy XVI (2023.)
Image


Final Fantasy XVI has this thing called Eikon battles, which are boss fights where both you and the enemy transform into giant monsters with elemental powers. They’re unapologetically not RPG battles, as your build isn’t taken into account, and are made more for the spectacle than anything. But that can work too, if done right. Hence: Bahamut, the Warden of Light.

In this fight, you switch between playing as protagonist Clive’s Ifrit, a devil-like melee fighter, and his brother’s Joshua’s Phoenix, who flies and shoots in a Panzer Dragoon gameplay style. The mechanics on both are kind of basic, hence why the boss is only number 10, and it’s not all that difficult, but it is still fun. His moveset only gets wilder and more imaginative as the fight goes on. The flying phase especially surprised me; I didn’t know there were still people who could make these.

But it’s really the style that put it above the rest. It’s gorgeous to look at, with the blue and black environments contrasting with Ifrit and Phoenix’s fire. It has a crucial role in the story, serving as the long-awaited reunion between the two brothers, and them just working perfectly together after being apart for so long was an adorable story detail. Musically, it’s an absolute slam-dunk, giving you a full course of the usual boss theme, then this banger signifying the return of Joshua, and finally a majestic quasi-waltz imbuing Bahamut with his due dignity. It’s a playable concert, I tell you. It’s Fantasia 2023.


#9. - Dragonlord Placidusax
Elden Ring (2022.)
Image


Speaking of Elden Ring and superbosses, this is exactly what I’m talking about. Placidusax is hidden off in an obscure corner of the Crumbling Farum Azula level, and you’re not meant to fight him until you’re level 100 or so. Presentation-wise, he justifies being a secret boss. The arena, the music, and his moveset denoting abilities and intelligence far beyond your garden variety dragon, all point to him being some sort of deity you should not be able to meet in the flesh. The lore even supports this.

If you’ve played the Dark Souls games, you should have a basic idea of how this fight plays. The dragonlord is still a dragon, after all. Fire breath, swooping attacks, claw strikes. Though, I’d argue he has one of the better dragon movesets in the series, thanks to his ability to turn to mist, two heads instead of one, and extended claw reach due to his lightning magic. You may even get an attack that’s so powerful it interrupts the music - see, details like that are what turns good games into great games.


#8. - Labyrinth Sentinel
Remnant 2 (2023.)
Image


If you ask me about Remnant 2, I’ll say it’s either God’s gift to the world or an unconfident soulslike with the personality of a cardboard box depending on what mood I’m in. But one thing that can’t be disputed is that it has one of the most original boss battles in this or any genre: Labyrinth Sentinel.

Imagine it as a mix of Pac-Man and Bloxorz, but within third-person shooter gameplay. You’re trapped in a small maze, where four stone cubes tumble around in pre-set patterns. Getting crushed by one is instant death. You have to shoot them all in their glowing weak points, which will create a hole in that side, rendering it effectively harmless. In addition, you have a set of flying cubes pelting you with normal attacks, ensuring you can’t stay in one spot for too long.

Written out like this, it’s easy to deride this boss as gimmicky, but it works. It’s a blast having to map this maze out in your mind, from a perspective where you can’t see it all at once. It’s precisely how action and puzzle elements should mix, and not to mention, the music is awesome.


#7. - The Dentist
Split Fiction (2025.)
Image



A product of one of the new faces of video game auteurship, Josef Fares, the Dentist fits into his style of kaleidoscopic two-player puzzle platforming to the degree that that is possible. It takes place in a side story, which are short, optional levels taking place in random stories written by one of the two protagonists. This is in one that Mio, the grumpy one, wrote as a little kid.

Not that this is the first piece of media to ever dramatize childrens’ fear of dentists, but it’s amazing how well it made it work in the context of a game. How you start off in a candy world and summon him by drawing a pentagram on a birthday cake, how your protagonists take the form of walking teeth and he attacks them with dental drills, how he immobilizes you with globs of toothpaste, or how he uses wind-up teeth1 toys as weapons. He’s a bit on the easy side, but the energy, creativity, and whimsy more than make up for it, especially coming from a developer who seeks to deliver exactly that. Don’t ever change, mr. Fares.


#6. - Jackenstein
Deltarune (2025.)
Image



‘‘You’re taking too long’’ - Jackenstein’s catchphrase, and one that sadly encapsulates Deltarune’s release schedule. Though, luckily for us, Toby Fox can still bring the thunder when he wants to. He’s been at this diplomatic bullet hell JRPG style for a decade now, and in the fourth and latest chapter of Deltarune, he has brought his most inspired and well-crafted boss battle yet.

A halloween-themed boss, Jackenstein is fought in the dark, and is immune to your basic attacks. The way to take him down is to play his bullet hell segments until you power up an illumination spell. Said segments, contrary to the usual fare, take the form of one of those Atari maze/horror games - if you watch the AVGN, you’ll know which ones - where you have to dodge obstacles and collect powerups with very limited vision, and run from a jack-o-lantern on the way out. One objective advantage this fight has over the rest of Deltarune is the amount of different attacks - most bosses will have four or five attack patterns, but Jackenstein has ten, and nine of them don’t ever repeat. That, combined with the spooktacular music, Scooby Doo-esque eyeballs in the dark, and mountains of hilarious jokes, makes this the most entertaining fight in Deltarune, and one of the best in any indie game, period.


#5. - Adam Smasher
Cyberpunk 2077 (2020.)
Image


In the original 2020. release, Adam was a passive and unintelligent boss. Not much to write home about. In 2023., CDPR released an update that rehauled him completely, inspired by the brutal interpretation of the character in the animated series Cyberpunk: Edgerunners, which I have not seen. That being said, the Adam Smasher we have now is violent, intelligent, difficult, and most importantly of all, flexible.

Designing the final boss of an RPG is not easy. As RPGs are all about build variety, it requires you to keep a lot of variables in mind - is it too easy for quickhack users? Is it too hard for stealth builds? Would it be fair for him to be immune to poison? This steely skinhead is one of the few that got it all right, no ifs, ands, or buts. If you’re built for direct combat, he’ll give you a frenetic, grueling gunfight. If you can do remote hacks, he’ll counter you with his own - alternatively, you could hack the dormant automated turrets in the room to distract him. If you’re a sneaky ninja, you can pull of some trick where you blind him, then get a short opportunity for a sneak attack. Three of those, and you win - they even have their distinct custom animations.

Adam has a lot less going on artistically than most of the bosses on this list, but the design is just so **** good, it earns him this high of a spot.


#4. - Samur Maykr
Doom Eternal - the Ancient Gods part 1 (2020.)
Image


Would you believe me if I said this is the only 10/10 fight in a pure FPS that I know of? It’s crazy. Despite having some of the best action games ever made - Shadow Warrior, Titanfall 2, Serious Sam - none of them have had a single stop-the-presses-level quality boss2, barring this little Seraph who could.

Samur is a form of Samuel Hayden from Doom 2016., a character whose best asset is his intelligence. It was shown at the end of that game that he is somewhat of a match for the Doom Slayer, his tricks and traps can find a ***** in his armour, and this battle reflects that. It takes place in a room rigged with laser grids, rising and falling platforms, electric floors, portals to summon in demons, magic that slows you down. It’s Saw, it’s Superman vs Lex Luthor, it’s Jaden vs Bastion, it’s Perry the Platypus escaping a trap. Samur is a cheater. Sometimes he fights you himself, sometimes he hides behind shields. At one point, he straight up teleports out of the arena and has you deal with a gauntlet of cacodemons. It works, because that’s what Eternal’s gameplay is built around: constant movement. It’s satisfying having to keep a constantly changing mental map of this death room, hard because of the amount of hazards you have to avoid, but not too much because you do still get an occasional chance to recover.

Also, the music was composed by Andrew Hulshult, who was the composer for DUSK. He was generally brought over for the DLC, and did a fantastic job.


#3. - guess

No, really. Guess who’s next.

Give yourself 10 seconds. See if you can get it right.



#3. - The Reaper
Vampire Survivors (2022.)
Image


^this noonie
No, I’m dead serious.

Ok so here’s the deal with this guy. Vampire Survivors is a rougelite where each round is timed at 30 minutes. After those 30 minutes are up, the Grim Reaper swoops in and instakills you. Except, not really - it’s not an instakill, his damage output is just really high, and you’ll likely see damage numbers coming off him if your weapons happen to have been firing at the moment he does you in. The seed has been planted: you can kill him.

Figuring out how is a good brain teaser, and encourages you to get familiar with the game. All the weapon combinations you can make, all the ways you can skew the odds in your favour. There’s a weapon that can freeze enemies, there’s one that blocks the first this or that many hits. You can reduce weapon cooldown. These two hard-to-reach powerups seem to be made for one another, but what do they do? This one character has two extra revives - would that be enough? How do I deal with his insane health pool? I’m not going to spoil how I beat him, but if you play the game for long enough, it’ll become clear to you too. It’s doable.

I just want to point out that the third best boss of the decade is from a game that costs six dollars. Ave Luca Galante, put him in a museum next to Dante and Da Vinci.


#2. - Erlang, the Sacred Divinity
Black Myth: Wukong (2024.)
Image

The top two fights on this list are both superbosses, and both are straight up perfect. First, let’s examine Erlang, the Sacred Divinity, a soulslike hack ‘n’ slash fight that embarrasses the competition.

He is set up in the game’s prologue, where you play as the original Sun Wukong. It’s just a tutorial fight that you can’t lose, but it lets you know where he stands in the game’s lore - the entire game basically taking place in that fight’s shadow. Though the actual final boss lets you test yourself against Sun Wukong and become worthy of his name, you can’t escape the feeling that there’s still unfinished business - would the Monkey King deny himself the chance to get even?

The path to Erlang is rather cryptic, and that makes it all the more shocking how much effort went into this entirely missable fight. His first form alone has four distinct phases, every phase transition occurring with a special, tailored attack. His moveset only gets deeper and deeper, adding magical floating weapons to the mix, alongside eye lasers, a hunting dog, and lightning magic. It’s all animated in a way that you can easily figure out the dodge timing, but it takes really good reaction time. On top of that, he has a number of tweaks, such as a depleteable shield that protects him from the front, or special attacks that break you out of your transformations if you don’t dodge them on time. All of that is peppered with mountains of well-written, well-acted dialogue, portraying Erlang as a spirited, extroverted, and charismatic character. He will have a different taunt for each transformation you try.

And that’s just his first form.

Well, the rest is like the Eikon battles from FFXVI. More about the spectacle than the challenge: you transform into a giant stone monkey, spar with the Four Heavenly Kings, then fight two phases of Erlang as a giant lion-man. It’s easy, but it’s imaginative and exciting. It’s hard not to crack a smile when one of the kings turns his umbrella into a stormy sky. Not to mention, you get to spend more time around Erlang. And you even part ways peacefully despite how hard you bodied him - good. If I had to kill this legend, I could never forgive myself.


#1. - Raphael
Baldur’s Gate III (2023.)

Image

Here are the reasons why Raphael is the best boss battle of the 2020s:

He’s theatrical.

He sings his own boss theme.

He has 666 hit points.

He hates kittens. I **** you not, he actually says that.

He was a dangerous presence in the game since the first chapter. He would badger you to make deals with him, and BG3 being the kind of RPG where your choices matter, the danger of getting gypped out of your soul is very real.

He offers you easy solutions to major questlines. The temptation to take up his offers is real.

The choices you made in the quest regarding his client-turned-enemy, Yurghir, come into play. If you played your cards right, he will be a valuable ally.

The preceding level, the House of Hope, strikes a great balance between being amusingly spoopy and genuinely uncomfortable.

The fact that he’s a devil is woven into the fight intelligently. For example, he can invoke debtors to act as cannon fodder, and absorb energy from enslaved souls to turn himself into a more physically powerful demon - something Doomguy would fight. It actually feels like you’re fighting a devil, not some prick that happens to have ‘‘devil’’ written on his character profile.

He’s genuinely hard. The cambion minions, mixed with the soul pillars scattered around the arena, force you to spread your party around. And none of them are pushovers - you have to prioritize targets and assign combat roles intelligently.

There’s an extra party member named Hope, one of Ralphie’s prisoners you helped break out. Not only does that add a layer of complexity that isn’t present in other fights, or weave the story into the gameplay, or give it a sense of gravity because the devs put in that bit of extra effort… it does all that, but most importantly, Hope and Raphael’s powers complement each other. She can invoke divine intervention, a powerful and tempting spell, but there’s a high probability that she’ll die if she uses it because Raphael has the Punish Divinity power. It’s an RPG, sometimes you gotta roll the dice.

He’s a theatrical devil with 666 hit points who sings his own theme song and hates kittens. How do you top that?
Debeli ronaldo, ja san debeli ronaldo, jedini pravi ronaldo
User avatar
rusty_shackleford
Site Admin
Posts: 45468
Joined: Feb 2, '23
Gender: Watermelon

Geolocation

Adventurer's Guild

Post by rusty_shackleford »

I do not care for bosses in video games.
Thank you for your attention to this matter!
Steam friend code: 40552640 https://steamcommunity.com/friends/add | email: [email protected]
Having trouble running an old Windows game?
Rusty's Stuff Collection
User avatar
rusty_shackleford
Site Admin
Posts: 45468
Joined: Feb 2, '23
Gender: Watermelon

Geolocation

Adventurer's Guild

Post by rusty_shackleford »

rusty_shackleford wrote: May 31st, 2026, 09:10
I do not care for bosses in video games.
Perhaps I should say that I don't actively hate them, but that they're so misused that I think games are better off not having them. Demon's Souls is the only game in recent memory that I've played which had enjoyable bosses, and people whine those bosses are "gimmick" encounters therefore the later games have "enemy, except very high stats" encounters.
Thank you for your attention to this matter!
Steam friend code: 40552640 https://steamcommunity.com/friends/add | email: [email protected]
Having trouble running an old Windows game?
Rusty's Stuff Collection
User avatar
Vlajdimir Ermenović
Posts: 647
Joined: Apr 18, '23
Location: a country
Gender: Lemon

Geolocation

Post by Vlajdimir Ermenović »

rusty_shackleford wrote: May 31st, 2026, 09:48
rusty_shackleford wrote: May 31st, 2026, 09:10
I do not care for bosses in video games.
Perhaps I should say that I don't actively hate them, but that they're so misused that I think games are better off not having them. Demon's Souls is the only game in recent memory that I've played which had enjoyable bosses, and people whine those bosses are "gimmick" encounters therefore the later games have "enemy, except very high stats" encounters.
Being gimmicky is really overhated, yes, and fromsoft bosses in general are not as interesting as they could be. Wow, a sword wielding human with sad music who kills you in one hit. Save some creativity for the rest of us, Da Vinci.
Debeli ronaldo, ja san debeli ronaldo, jedini pravi ronaldo
User avatar
rusty_shackleford
Site Admin
Posts: 45468
Joined: Feb 2, '23
Gender: Watermelon

Geolocation

Adventurer's Guild

Post by rusty_shackleford »

Vlajdimir Ermenović wrote: May 31st, 2026, 10:17
rusty_shackleford wrote: May 31st, 2026, 09:48
rusty_shackleford wrote: May 31st, 2026, 09:10
I do not care for bosses in video games.
Perhaps I should say that I don't actively hate them, but that they're so misused that I think games are better off not having them. Demon's Souls is the only game in recent memory that I've played which had enjoyable bosses, and people whine those bosses are "gimmick" encounters therefore the later games have "enemy, except very high stats" encounters.
Being gimmicky is really overhated, yes, and fromsoft bosses in general are not as interesting as they could be. Wow, a sword wielding human with sad music who kills you in one hit. Save some creativity for the rest of us, Da Vinci.
Everything that isn't just rote memorization is called a gimmick. It's ok for bosses to have entirely unique mechanics as long as you're actually using your character to engage in said mechanics rather than as a substitute for your character.
Thank you for your attention to this matter!
Steam friend code: 40552640 https://steamcommunity.com/friends/add | email: [email protected]
Having trouble running an old Windows game?
Rusty's Stuff Collection
User avatar
Valter
Posts: 1739
Joined: Jun 12, '24

Geolocation

Adventurer's Guild

Post by Valter »

What do you think of the Paintress and the Sirene boss fights in E33? I enjoyed them more than Simon. Those felt like the best finetuned bosses in the game in terms of appropriate difficulty, with decently diverse attack repertoires that Simon lacked.

Edit: Sirene, not Seamstress
Last edited by Valter on May 31st, 2026, 11:06, edited 1 time in total.
Steam friend code: 1525876263
User avatar
Vlajdimir Ermenović
Posts: 647
Joined: Apr 18, '23
Location: a country
Gender: Lemon

Geolocation

Post by Vlajdimir Ermenović »

Valter wrote: May 31st, 2026, 10:44
What do you think of the Paintress and the Seamstress boss fights in E33? I enjoyed them more than Simon. Those felt like the best finetuned bosses in the game in terms of appropriate difficulty, with decently diverse attack repertoires that Simon lacked.
The Paintress, Osquio, Painted Clea, and Sirene were all considered for the list. Alas, I just like these 10 bosses better.
Debeli ronaldo, ja san debeli ronaldo, jedini pravi ronaldo
User avatar
rusty_shackleford
Site Admin
Posts: 45468
Joined: Feb 2, '23
Gender: Watermelon

Geolocation

Adventurer's Guild

Post by rusty_shackleford »

roguelite, unless it was an intentional misspelling
Thank you for your attention to this matter!
Steam friend code: 40552640 https://steamcommunity.com/friends/add | email: [email protected]
Having trouble running an old Windows game?
Rusty's Stuff Collection
User avatar
Vlajdimir Ermenović
Posts: 647
Joined: Apr 18, '23
Location: a country
Gender: Lemon

Geolocation

Post by Vlajdimir Ermenović »

rusty_shackleford wrote: May 31st, 2026, 10:57
roguelite, unless it was an intentional misspelling
I will never, ever, ever, ever, ever remember which one is rogue and which one is rouge without looking it up. And I say that regularly typing that word into the e621 search bar.
Debeli ronaldo, ja san debeli ronaldo, jedini pravi ronaldo
User avatar
TKVNC
Posts: 3081
Joined: Feb 25, '24

Geolocation

Adventurer's Guild

Post by TKVNC »

rusty_shackleford wrote: May 31st, 2026, 09:48
rusty_shackleford wrote: May 31st, 2026, 09:10
I do not care for bosses in video games.
Perhaps I should say that I don't actively hate them, but that they're so misused that I think games are better off not having them. Demon's Souls is the only game in recent memory that I've played which had enjoyable bosses, and people whine those bosses are "gimmick" encounters therefore the later games have "enemy, except very high stats" encounters.
KCD1 had good boss design, for what it is worth.

In the Runt fight, he's still a threat unless you bring a mace, and just bash his head in. So too for Black Peter. It was refreshing to have no gimicks.
User avatar
Tweed
Turtle
Turtle
Posts: 6837
Joined: Feb 2, '23

Geolocation

Adventurer's Guild

Post by Tweed »

Vlajdimir Ermenović wrote: May 31st, 2026, 11:00
rusty_shackleford wrote: May 31st, 2026, 10:57
roguelite, unless it was an intentional misspelling
I will never, ever, ever, ever, ever remember which one is rogue and which one is rouge without looking it up. And I say that regularly typing that word into the e621 search bar.
********.png
You do not have the required permissions to view the files attached to this post.
User avatar
Val the Moofia Boss
Turtle
Turtle
Posts: 4198
Joined: Jun 3, '23

Geolocation

Adventurer's Guild

Post by Val the Moofia Boss »

Echo of Neltharion from World of Warcraft: Dragonflight. The penultimate boss of the Abberus raid. A very intense fight as he is constantly raising earth walls dividing the room into quadrants trying to trap you and kill you with AoEs. He has a powerful knockback that the tank has to aim so that they will be knocked into one earth wall to destroy it, but he has to be careful that he only gets thrown through one because it causes massive raid wide damage and if he gets thrown through two or more it will probably kill everyone else. You have to burst down adds really fast or die. Rising orchestral music. Very stressful.

WoW Dragonflight campaign no commentary part 9 - Aberrus, the Shadowed Crucible (Normal)
User avatar
methoxetamine
Posts: 1736
Joined: Apr 18, '25
Location: Kamurocho

Geolocation

Post by methoxetamine »

Val the Moofia Boss wrote: May 31st, 2026, 19:25
Echo of Neltharion from World of Warcraft: Dragonflight. The penultimate boss of the Abberus raid. A very intense fight as he is constantly raising earth walls dividing the room into quadrants trying to trap you and kill you with AoEs. He has a powerful knockback that the tank has to aim so that they will be knocked into one earth wall to destroy it, but he has to be careful that he only gets thrown through one because it causes massive raid wide damage and if he gets thrown through two or more it will probably kill everyone else. You have to burst down adds really fast or die. Rising orchestral music. Very stressful.

WoW Dragonflight campaign no commentary part 9 - Aberrus, the Shadowed Crucible (Normal)
I hate this piece of ****. Absolutely excruciating to prog on Mythic, and on Heroic there's just too much downtime and the AOE phase is frustrating because everything dies in a split second
asf wrote:
weeb
User avatar
Vlajdimir Ermenović
Posts: 647
Joined: Apr 18, '23
Location: a country
Gender: Lemon

Geolocation

Post by Vlajdimir Ermenović »

Wow is still a thing?
Debeli ronaldo, ja san debeli ronaldo, jedini pravi ronaldo
User avatar
methoxetamine
Posts: 1736
Joined: Apr 18, '25
Location: Kamurocho

Geolocation

Post by methoxetamine »

@Vlajdimir Ermenović go play Nine Sols and get the true ending and report back with your new list with the final boss at #1
asf wrote:
weeb
User avatar
Val the Moofia Boss
Turtle
Turtle
Posts: 4198
Joined: Jun 3, '23

Geolocation

Adventurer's Guild

Post by Val the Moofia Boss »

Vlajdimir Ermenović wrote: May 31st, 2026, 19:33
Wow is still a thing?
Yes. The thread gets active whenever a new expansion or patch drops.
User avatar
stormvermin
Posts: 272
Joined: Apr 30, '25

Geolocation

Adventurer's Guild

Post by stormvermin »

the labyrinth sentinel was the biggest roadblock of my hardcore remnant 2 endeavor. it's nowhere near the hardest boss but a single mistake put so many attempts in the dirt.
User avatar
Vlajdimir Ermenović
Posts: 647
Joined: Apr 18, '23
Location: a country
Gender: Lemon

Geolocation

Post by Vlajdimir Ermenović »

methoxetamine wrote: May 31st, 2026, 19:33
@Vlajdimir Ermenović go play Nine Sols and get the true ending and report back with your new list with the final boss at #1
I'm aware of Eigong, I tried Nine Sols for her alone, and got bored of the game fairly quickly. Parry, parry, parry, parry, do generic metroidvania business, parry, parry.

Also, refer to what I said in the dishonorable mentions: just because it's hard, doesn't mean it's good. It's still a 2d game with a combat system we've all seen before.
Debeli ronaldo, ja san debeli ronaldo, jedini pravi ronaldo
User avatar
Oyster Sauce
Site Moderator
Posts: 11293
Joined: Jun 2, '23

Geolocation

Adventurer's Guild

Post by Oyster Sauce »

I have absolutely no sense of time when it comes to game releases. Elden Ring could have been 2024 or 2021 or 2019 for all I know.
User avatar
J1M
Turtle
Turtle
Posts: 5068
Joined: Feb 15, '23

Geolocation

Adventurer's Guild

Post by J1M »

rusty_shackleford wrote: May 31st, 2026, 09:48
rusty_shackleford wrote: May 31st, 2026, 09:10
I do not care for bosses in video games.
Perhaps I should say that I don't actively hate them, but that they're so misused that I think games are better off not having them. Demon's Souls is the only game in recent memory that I've played which had enjoyable bosses, and people whine those bosses are "gimmick" encounters therefore the later games have "enemy, except very high stats" encounters.
Gameplay needs climactic encounters, the same way a story needs a climax.

I think your characterization of gimmicks is broader than mine, and I don't mind having my gameplay mixed up by something like using the item I found in the Zelda dungeon to stun a boss. However, if the same level of critique is turned to standard encounters, are they all just 'grinding'?
User avatar
Val the Moofia Boss
Turtle
Turtle
Posts: 4198
Joined: Jun 3, '23

Geolocation

Adventurer's Guild

Post by Val the Moofia Boss »

You usually have more freedom to interact with regular mobs. You can sleep them, mind control, paralyze, confuse, kite, etc. Bosses are typically resistant to all CC and debuffs, cannot be kited out of their arena, cannot be mind controlled, etc. A large reason why WoW M+ became popular is because it is about trash fights and how you interact with them. The first few years of MDI were interesting to watch because of all of the crazy strats involved trash mobs, like a Mistweaver monk entering a boss room first, placing down his teleport recall, aggroing all of the trash, and then running away and kiting the mobs out of the room while the rest of the party goes in and engages the boss. And then when the monk runs out of room to kite the mobs, he teleports back to the boos room and helps out. Or Tirna Scithe where players figured out they could bring a priest and mindcontrol a powerful mob and then using its unique attack the bypass a boss' heavy defense.
asf
Turtle
Turtle
Posts: 3176
Joined: Feb 2, '23
Gender: Helicopter

Geolocation

Post by asf »

console garbage
User avatar
J1M
Turtle
Turtle
Posts: 5068
Joined: Feb 15, '23

Geolocation

Adventurer's Guild

Post by J1M »

Val the Moofia Boss wrote: May 31st, 2026, 20:25
You usually have more freedom to interact with regular mobs. You can sleep them, mind control, paralyze, confuse, kite, etc. Bosses are typically resistant to all CC and debuffs, cannot be kited out of their arena, cannot be mind controlled, etc. A large reason why WoW M+ became popular is because it is about trash fights and how you interact with them. The first few years of MDI were interesting to watch because of all of the crazy strats involved trash mobs, like a Mistweaver monk entering a boss room first, placing down his teleport recall, aggroing all of the trash, and then running away and kiting the mobs out of the room while the rest of the party goes in and engages the boss. And then when the monk runs out of room to kite the mobs, he teleports back to the boos room and helps out. Or Tirna Scithe where players figured out they could bring a priest and mindcontrol a powerful mob and then using its unique attack the bypass a boss' heavy defense.
If think if designers care about this that the stagger meter is a decent band-aid to allow crowd control effects to contribute to boss encounters. Basically, once enough CC is put into the boss the meter is depleted and they are stunned for a while.
User avatar
rusty_shackleford
Site Admin
Posts: 45468
Joined: Feb 2, '23
Gender: Watermelon

Geolocation

Adventurer's Guild

Post by rusty_shackleford »

J1M wrote: May 31st, 2026, 20:08
rusty_shackleford wrote: May 31st, 2026, 09:48
rusty_shackleford wrote: May 31st, 2026, 09:10
I do not care for bosses in video games.
Perhaps I should say that I don't actively hate them, but that they're so misused that I think games are better off not having them. Demon's Souls is the only game in recent memory that I've played which had enjoyable bosses, and people whine those bosses are "gimmick" encounters therefore the later games have "enemy, except very high stats" encounters.
Gameplay needs climactic encounters, the same way a story needs a climax.

I think your characterization of gimmicks is broader than mine, and I don't mind having my gameplay mixed up by something like using the item I found in the Zelda dungeon to stun a boss. However, if the same level of critique is turned to standard encounters, are they all just 'grinding'?
You can do it just fine without having a big single boss. A well designed encounter can be a climactic encounter just fine.

The most memorable encounter in divinity original sin 2 for me is the Red Prince assassin encounter where they take you completely off guard with no warning out of stealth and cover your group in smoke. They're given complete advantage and you're at every disadvantage. Didn't require giving them special abilities or anything.
Thank you for your attention to this matter!
Steam friend code: 40552640 https://steamcommunity.com/friends/add | email: [email protected]
Having trouble running an old Windows game?
Rusty's Stuff Collection
User avatar
J1M
Turtle
Turtle
Posts: 5068
Joined: Feb 15, '23

Geolocation

Adventurer's Guild

Post by J1M »

rusty_shackleford wrote: June 1st, 2026, 08:29
J1M wrote: May 31st, 2026, 20:08
rusty_shackleford wrote: May 31st, 2026, 09:48


Perhaps I should say that I don't actively hate them, but that they're so misused that I think games are better off not having them. Demon's Souls is the only game in recent memory that I've played which had enjoyable bosses, and people whine those bosses are "gimmick" encounters therefore the later games have "enemy, except very high stats" encounters.
Gameplay needs climactic encounters, the same way a story needs a climax.

I think your characterization of gimmicks is broader than mine, and I don't mind having my gameplay mixed up by something like using the item I found in the Zelda dungeon to stun a boss. However, if the same level of critique is turned to standard encounters, are they all just 'grinding'?
You can do it just fine without having a big single boss. A well designed encounter can be a climactic encounter just fine.

The most memorable encounter in divinity original sin 2 for me is the Red Prince assassin encounter where they take you completely off guard with no warning out of stealth and cover your group in smoke. They're given complete advantage and you're at every disadvantage. Didn't require giving them special abilities or anything.
I agree that a great encounter doesn't need to include a new enemy type. Though that is an easy way to communicate to the player.

In general, I find that games don't do what you described. They are just lazy and have the same enemies attack in the same way. Perhaps increasing the number involved by 30%.

Creating a boss creature puts something of a minimum standard in place for complacent game devs to create some sort of climactic (boss) encounter.
User avatar
maidenhaver
Posts: 9452
Joined: Apr 17, '23
Location: ROLE PLAYING GAME

Geolocation

Adventurer's Guild

Post by maidenhaver »

User avatar
Vlajdimir Ermenović
Posts: 647
Joined: Apr 18, '23
Location: a country
Gender: Lemon

Geolocation

Post by Vlajdimir Ermenović »

I updated the list to remove Placidusax and wedge an entry between Jackenstein and Adam Smasher. I don't want from software and their depressed dreary autistic nihilism on here. Will do the same with Labyrinth Sentinel once I figure out what to replace it with.
#6. - Renoir Dessendre/The Curator
Clair Obscur: Expedition 33 (2025.)

Image

Speaking of Clair Obscur, this is exactly what I was talking about when I said it was above philistinism. It has many artistically accomplished boss battles, the best of the bunch being, somewhat obviously, the final boss. That has to do with the fact that one of Clair Obscur’s best assets is its story, and the fight against Renoir was a conclusion that did not disappoint. By now, you’re well aware that the world you’ve been occupying the whole game is in fact just a magical painting, where little Alicia Dessendre took refuge after being disfigured in a house fire, her father Renoir and mother Aline fighting about whether she should be pulled back out or not. It’s a real heart-breaking scenario where it’s hard not to feel for each participant, bolstered by a dramatic vocal track and a spectacular vocal performance by Andy Serkis.

It’s a believable blend of deeply personal stakes and world-ending spectacle, seeing as how Renoir did have a hand in creating this world. That is brought across in gameplay in two ways. First, his attacks utilizing a protean black material called ‘‘void’’, which in the context of a painted world feels like some primordial force. Second, in his midway phase transition, he summons the ‘‘Axons’’ - five giants who presented a big hurdle to overcome in the early game, now reduced to his support. It all feels like you’re on the verge of physically transcending this universe.

His difficulty is a point of contention for most people, as it’s hard to know at what exact level to fight him. I can only speak from my own experience, and I fought him at level 50-ish, and without removing the damage cap. He gave me good, fair challenge; it was fun to figure out the parry timing for all his well-animated attacks, it was fun setting up the right party structure and strategies, and it took me 3 days. If you ask me, that’s exactly how difficult he should be.
Debeli ronaldo, ja san debeli ronaldo, jedini pravi ronaldo