The moment you've all been waiting for!
For those that haven't been keeping up, we have a year lag in our RPGOTY to give people at least a year to play and digest the games that have been released. All votes cast were made by members of the community who actively post on the forum.
The Little Game That Could Award
Caves of Lore
Coming in just a couple votes behind second place is still impressive for a small title made by one guy. An excellent little game with a lot of love and care put into it, go check out our full review written by @Kalarion!
Sixteen Times The Disappointment Award

First Place Losers Award
Warhammer 40K: Rogue Trader
Rogue Trader also boasts an excellent soundtrack composed by Pavel Lipski.
► Show Spoiler

Jagged Alliance 3
People's Poor Choice Award:
Baldur's Gate 3

Many of us agree that the first act is excellent going by the vote total, and a good first impression leaves a strong impact. The game is still unfinished with many features cut weeks prior to release, Larian seemingly severed ties with Wizard of the Coast and there will be no definitive version. Despite this, the game featured strong reactivity, interactivity, and developer foresight. Check out our thread on it!
HQ RPG 2023 Award
Hero's Adventure: Road to Passion

What did you think this is, a democracy?
A small Chinese studio made an amazing RPG with heavy reactivity & freedom of choice. A charming artstyle and excellent soundtrack, this title has very few flaws worth mentioning. Check out our thread on it!