We have a Steam curator now. You should be following it. https://store.steampowered.com/curator/44994899-RPGHQ/

Game Romances that Aren't Cringe

For discussing role-playing video games, you know, the ones with combat.
User avatar
Nessa
Posts: 37
Joined: Dec 3, '23

Game Romances that Aren't Cringe

Post by Nessa »

So the question is, do any actually exist?

I've been thinking about it and I can't come up with a single base game romance that wasn't just dumb/hilarious/cringe.

Off the top of my head in no particular order:
  • Witcher 3 -- You'd think this would be better but I was dying during any of the "romance" scenes.
  • Anything Bethesda -- Please. :lol:
  • Dragon Age -- I never actually played any in this series but I saw some of them on Youtube. Absolutely hilarious cringe! :lol:
  • Mass Effect Series -- Cringe. Cringe. And more cringe.
I can think of some mods for games that had great romance but that's it.

Has anybody actually run into a game with great romance?

Tags:
User avatar
rusty_shackleford
Site Admin
Posts: 10315
Joined: Feb 2, '23
Contact:

Post by rusty_shackleford »

Divinity: Original Sin was designed to be played with your girlfriend/wife, and the main characters are written as eternal lovers.

I think any romance that isn't originally written as a romance will be bad. By that, I mean any "video game romance" you see in many games now, where you try to woo someone over time.
Last edited by rusty_shackleford on February 28th, 2024, 03:53, edited 1 time in total.
User avatar
asf
Turtle
Turtle
Posts: 503
Joined: Feb 2, '23

Post by asf »

game romances that aren't cringy:
► Show Spoiler
User avatar
Nammu Archag
Posts: 1032
Joined: Nov 28, '23
Location: Tel Uvirith

Post by Nammu Archag »

Nessa wrote: February 28th, 2024, 03:46
So the question is, do any actually exist?

I've been thinking about it and I can't come up with a single base game romance that wasn't just dumb/hilarious/cringe.

Off the top of my head in no particular order:
  • Witcher 3 -- You'd think this would be better but I was dying during any of the "romance" scenes.
  • Anything Bethesda -- Please. :lol:
  • Dragon Age -- I never actually played any in this series but I saw some of them on Youtube. Absolutely hilarious cringe! :lol:
  • Mass Effect Series -- Cringe. Cringe. And more cringe.
I can think of some mods for games that had great romance but that's it.

Has anybody actually run into a game with great romance?
If I'm being honest most actual romances are cringe/dumb
User avatar
Vergil
Posts: 3332
Joined: Sep 6, '23

Post by Vergil »

The only game that mildly made me feel okay with it was KOTOR II because you can use character's feelings for you to manipulate them (Handmaiden) :twisted: or basically say that there might be feelings there but there's no time for that kind of shit right now (Visas).
User avatar
ArcaneLurker
Posts: 890
Joined: Feb 6, '24

Post by ArcaneLurker »

I'm okay with the cringe as long as I like the character and I'm learning more about them.
User avatar
Oyster Sauce
Turtle
Turtle
Posts: 2092
Joined: Jun 2, '23

Post by Oyster Sauce »

The only one I can remember disliking is Kingmaker's Valerie, who after an entire campaign of romance spent our first date getting drunk and telling me stories about having sex with some other guy.
That's pretty bad, but at least I wasn't one of the poor fools who fell for Shadowheart. She's far more openly disgusting.
Last edited by Oyster Sauce on February 28th, 2024, 04:07, edited 1 time in total.
User avatar
orinEsque
Posts: 1588
Joined: Oct 9, '23
Location: Narnia

Post by orinEsque »

Alistair from Dragon Age Origins.
Silly, Funny, and turns out to have quite an inheritance. Overall, not a prince charming, but charming.

I heard good things about Cullen from Dragon Age Inquisition. I didn't finish it to get to the romance part, because I got bored half way.
User avatar
Nammu Archag
Posts: 1032
Joined: Nov 28, '23
Location: Tel Uvirith

Post by Nammu Archag »

I like games where you can have a hot, evil/crazy gf, as it is the closest I can get to that without putting myself in harm's way again, though maybe those types would be considered cringey to others
User avatar
ArcaneLurker
Posts: 890
Joined: Feb 6, '24

Post by ArcaneLurker »

Oyster Sauce wrote: February 28th, 2024, 04:07
The only one I can remember disliking is Kingmaker's Valerie, who after an entire campaign of romance spent our first date getting drunk and telling me stories about having sex with some other guy.
That's pretty bad, but at least I wasn't one of the poor fools who fell for Shadowheart. She's far more openly disgusting.
Even in this case, I'm learning that she's not as likeable as I first thought. So real.
User avatar
Silver
Posts: 140
Joined: Dec 4, '23

Post by Silver »

I enjoyed Cullen romance from DAI, mostly because I liked his character in DA2, but you don't really get to know him there much and I had some attachment from playing DA2 at a young age.
Like any DAI romance -- it is cringe at times, but out of all of them I'd say Cullen was just "vanilla and lovely" in a good way.

Other than that, Divinity: Original Sin is the best.
User avatar
BobT
Posts: 846
Joined: Jan 29, '24
Location: USA

Post by BobT »

@Nessa Does this mean Romance as in where classical Romance happens in a game's story? (Such as between two NPCs)
Or the new-style "Romance" in Mass Effect, BG3 etc. where you chat up a character for a sex scene? (And that's specifically for the player character).
User avatar
Vergil
Posts: 3332
Joined: Sep 6, '23

Post by Vergil »

Silver wrote: February 28th, 2024, 04:23
I enjoyed Cullen romance from DAI, mostly because I liked his character in DA2, but you don't really get to know him there much and I had some attachment from playing DA2 at a young age.
Like any DAI romance -- it is cringe at times, but out of all of them I'd say Cullen was just "vanilla and lovely" in a good way.
I can see why Cullen would be enjoyable compared to the rest of the cast which are entirely odd dysgenic freaks.
User avatar
maidenhaver
Posts: 4263
Joined: Apr 17, '23
Location: ROLE PLAYING GAME
Contact:

Post by maidenhaver »

Its impossible. Unless you are James Bond or Shepard.
User avatar
Reeb
Closed Account
Posts: 36
Joined: Feb 26, '24

Post by Reeb »

Bastila in kotor 1. Maybe I have nostalgia goggles but having her betray the Jedi and republic for you and having her complete devotion as your lieutenant/lover while you become space emperor is just too good.
Last edited by Reeb on March 1st, 2024, 02:36, edited 2 times in total.
User avatar
Vergil
Posts: 3332
Joined: Sep 6, '23

Post by Vergil »

Any game that has characters with real likes/dislikes and will set boundaries is at least less cringe than ones where it's a weird playersexual real doll. This is why there has never been a good companion mod for a bethesda game btw.
User avatar
Falksi
Posts: 32
Joined: Nov 12, '23

Post by Falksi »

Phantasy Star 3. Vital to the plot and game progression, minimal bullshit involved, like you don't even chat to the fanny, you're top cock and so you simply dictate who you will marry and breed with.

Witcher 2's relationship with Triss was well done too. Felt like a nice side distraction within context of the game, rather than a major focus.

Dragon Age:Origins was cringe for the most part, but Claudia Black still managed to make romancing Morrigan enjoyable. Honestly, I think her voice could make the phrase "I've just shit blood" sound sexy though.
Last edited by Falksi on February 28th, 2024, 10:08, edited 3 times in total.
User avatar
maidenhaver
Posts: 4263
Joined: Apr 17, '23
Location: ROLE PLAYING GAME
Contact:

Post by maidenhaver »

God of War 1 where you bed three bitches at once and they pay you.
User avatar
Irenaeus
Posts: 941
Joined: Sep 29, '23

Post by Irenaeus »

Zelda 2 has a romance that isn't cringe. After you retrieve the Triforce of Courage, you return to wake up Zelda from the magic sleep and get to stay with her and likely live happily ever after. See here:

User avatar
maidenhaver
Posts: 4263
Joined: Apr 17, '23
Location: ROLE PLAYING GAME
Contact:

Post by maidenhaver »

GTA3 where you kill the psycho latina gf. Also, a very cozy game set in 90s new york.
User avatar
Oyster Sauce
Turtle
Turtle
Posts: 2092
Joined: Jun 2, '23

Post by Oyster Sauce »

Are there any romances in video games with BPD hellwomen that make your life a living nightmare but are very attractive?
User avatar
Vergil
Posts: 3332
Joined: Sep 6, '23

Post by Vergil »

Oyster Sauce wrote: February 28th, 2024, 10:42
Are there any romances in video games with BPD hellwomen that make your life a living nightmare but are very attractive?
If you have jungle fever the negress in Farcry 3 stabs you to death during sex if you take the bad ending.
User avatar
SoLong
Posts: 411
Joined: Oct 7, '23

Post by SoLong »

orinEsque wrote: February 28th, 2024, 04:08
Alistair from Dragon Age Origins.
Silly, Funny, and turns out to have quite an inheritance. Overall, not a prince charming, but charming.

I heard good things about Cullen from Dragon Age Inquisition. I didn't finish it to get to the romance part, because I got bored half way.
DA:I suffers from some very bad design decision, and I say that as someone who liked the game. Making your first map the largest one was guranteed to result in people getting lost/frustrated because leaving something unfinished goes against every single videogame instinct of the last few decades.
User avatar
Oyster Sauce
Turtle
Turtle
Posts: 2092
Joined: Jun 2, '23

Post by Oyster Sauce »

Vergil wrote: February 28th, 2024, 06:22
Any game that has characters with real likes/dislikes and will set boundaries is at least less cringe than ones where it's a weird playersexual real doll. This is why there has never been a good companion mod for a bethesda game btw.
Interestingly enough it seems DA:I had racial/religious preferences. From a very gay Reddit post:
This guy is underselling it.

Sera is a textbook example of emotional abuse if you romance her as an elf.

Sera is a victim of emotional abuse and internalized racism, but she perpetuates that same emotional abuse and self-loathing onto her fellow minority girlfriend.

She forces you to admit that your race is bad, that your traditions are dumb, etcetera. And if you say or do something she doesn't like she'll often flip her lid and call you names until you tell her what she wants to hear, while rarely showing the same consideration for your feelings and often blithely dismissing your offended reaction. Even threatening to break it off with you unless you denounce your own religion and people.

If you try to react to it she just dismisses it and you can never progress without quieting down or accepting her views.

In general she treats you just really badly compared to if you romance her as any other race whatsoever. For example if a Non-Elven Inquisitor romancing her claims they believe what they saw at The Temple of Mythal, Sera will call you stupid but agree to disagree while claiming she'd never dump someone over their beliefs. However, if an Elven Inquisitor so much as hesitates to agree with Sera that it's all fake/"demon worship," she does just that. And then calls you names and more or less refuses to talk to you for the rest of the game.

This even carries over into gameplay, say you flirt with her as a human, and you get a "Great Approval"?

If you're an elf you might only get "Slight Approval".

She will also constantly demand that you prove that you aren't "elfy" too her. Like everytime elven stuff comes up you have to be negative towards elves and their lore or she will dump you or call you names or threaten to dump you, etcetera

She literally psychologically goads you into doing her will. All the while giving you lovely dialogue like

She also openly admits she only likes you as long as you don't act too elfy, and as long as the relationship is fun and easy for her.

And it never gets brought up by anyone else, so I dunno if it is supposed to be an abusive relationship or if the writer likes this kinda treatment or what. They just wrote it like that and said "Yeah that is romance".

A perfect example is in the break up scene with her after the Temple of Mythal scene. Link here Where she breaks up with you over your faith and blames you for it! There's also of course the alternate version where she pulls a bow on you and gets upset at you for calling her out on the bullshit of threatening to kill her girlfriend.
Bioware actually does a few interesting and realistic things when it comes to romance in RPGs. For example: the black guy who cheats on you and knocks up another woman, a romance option that just fucking dies of Space Cancer in the middle of the game no matter what, a friend who becomes gay and starts making disturbing sexual advances towards you, the companion who manipulates and then straight up murders you if you have sex with her.
User avatar
Metalhead33
Posts: 295
Joined: Feb 26, '24

Post by Metalhead33 »

The original Baldur's Gate 2 had okay-ish romances, methinks. Sadly, the same cannot be said for its successor.
User avatar
Vergil
Posts: 3332
Joined: Sep 6, '23

Post by Vergil »

Oyster Sauce wrote: February 28th, 2024, 11:15
Vergil wrote: February 28th, 2024, 06:22
Any game that has characters with real likes/dislikes and will set boundaries is at least less cringe than ones where it's a weird playersexual real doll. This is why there has never been a good companion mod for a bethesda game btw.
Interestingly enough it seems DA:I had racial/religious preferences. From a very gay Reddit post:
This guy is underselling it.

Sera is a textbook example of emotional abuse if you romance her as an elf.

Sera is a victim of emotional abuse and internalized racism, but she perpetuates that same emotional abuse and self-loathing onto her fellow minority girlfriend.

She forces you to admit that your race is bad, that your traditions are dumb, etcetera. And if you say or do something she doesn't like she'll often flip her lid and call you names until you tell her what she wants to hear, while rarely showing the same consideration for your feelings and often blithely dismissing your offended reaction. Even threatening to break it off with you unless you denounce your own religion and people.

If you try to react to it she just dismisses it and you can never progress without quieting down or accepting her views.

In general she treats you just really badly compared to if you romance her as any other race whatsoever. For example if a Non-Elven Inquisitor romancing her claims they believe what they saw at The Temple of Mythal, Sera will call you stupid but agree to disagree while claiming she'd never dump someone over their beliefs. However, if an Elven Inquisitor so much as hesitates to agree with Sera that it's all fake/"demon worship," she does just that. And then calls you names and more or less refuses to talk to you for the rest of the game.

This even carries over into gameplay, say you flirt with her as a human, and you get a "Great Approval"?

If you're an elf you might only get "Slight Approval".

She will also constantly demand that you prove that you aren't "elfy" too her. Like everytime elven stuff comes up you have to be negative towards elves and their lore or she will dump you or call you names or threaten to dump you, etcetera

She literally psychologically goads you into doing her will. All the while giving you lovely dialogue like

She also openly admits she only likes you as long as you don't act too elfy, and as long as the relationship is fun and easy for her.

And it never gets brought up by anyone else, so I dunno if it is supposed to be an abusive relationship or if the writer likes this kinda treatment or what. They just wrote it like that and said "Yeah that is romance".

A perfect example is in the break up scene with her after the Temple of Mythal scene. Link here Where she breaks up with you over your faith and blames you for it! There's also of course the alternate version where she pulls a bow on you and gets upset at you for calling her out on the bullshit of threatening to kill her girlfriend.
Bioware actually does a few interesting and realistic things when it comes to romance in RPGs. For example: the black guy who cheats on you and knocks up another woman, a romance option that just fucking dies of Space Cancer in the middle of the game no matter what, a friend who becomes gay and starts making disturbing sexual advances towards you, the companion who manipulates and then straight up murders you if you have sex with her.
Cisquisition kept having moment where I almost liked the game genuinely until something gay/retarded/gay&retarded would happen. Too much MMO tier filler content too.
User avatar
Lord of Riva
Posts: 180
Joined: Feb 22, '24

Post by Lord of Riva »

Metalhead33 wrote: February 28th, 2024, 11:25
The original Baldur's Gate 2 had okay-ish romances, methinks. Sadly, the same cannot be said for its successor.
Can't confirm, they may be okayish with 16-20 but once you are a bit more an adult they are pretty "special".
Post Reply