We have a Steam curator now. You should be following it. https://store.steampowered.com/curator/44994899-RPGHQ/

Legends of Amberland II: The Song of Trees

For discussing role-playing video games, you know, the ones with combat.
Post Reply
User avatar
Rand
Posts: 1652
Joined: Sep 4, '23
Location: On my last legs

Legends of Amberland II: The Song of Trees

Post by Rand »

This is a quick, placeholder review while I get my shit together and flesh it out with comparisons to the first game and a bit more detail.
I'm slow, lazy, and a bit retarded, so please be patient.
Image

Just finished it:

Image

Brief review for a brief game:
• On the old X-Play review scale 3/5: okay game rating. Worth playing if you're bored and like blobbers, but there's nothing special about it. Overpriced at $20+ in my opinion.
• Game worked fine, but the text has some bugs, including unlinked text to message plaques in a few places.
• It would be nice if the game kept notes about where you found important people like skill trainers. I forgot where one was an had to consult a guide.
• Skill trainers are not well laid out to pace them over the game. The best is the magic points trainers. The worst is the haggling trainers. (By the time you find #2, you'll just teleport to #3 because you found him way earlier.)
• Balance/area design is shaky with too many low level monster areas you just slice through at high level without any thought. One of the end areas you enter at about level 50 has only level 7 enemies you will likely one-hit with your melee front-liners.
• Randomized items in shops and chests leads to a lot of not useful junk items that sell for basically nothing (even the powerful ones).
• A daily healer spell (Iron Skin) completely negates the need for the use of anti-paralysis/petrification items the moment you get it pretty early on.
• Bards have two support spells to contribute that are nice to have but not essential like the healer class' Iron Skin spell. Otherwise not really useful. They can remove fear, but this should have been a healer magic, of course it wasn't so as to give bards something to (almost never) contribute.
• No real strategy to combat, other than to know to flee if you're in trouble.
• Special abilities are once per rest, not per in-game day. This makes some sense for the recovery abilities of mages and healers, but makes the abilities of the various fighting classes one-shots that are not actually useful.
• There is no real build variety. You'd be mad to put points into anything except knowledge for melee fighters (crit chance), dex for archers (they don't get a lot of extra crit from knowledge like the other fighters), and willpower for casters (mana points).

• One major difference is the effect resistance. You are no longer just immune/not immune to a special effect. You have a total rating per element/effect and it's compared to the power of the enemy/trap inflicting the potential effect/damage. Enemies use their level as the power. Traps are set to specific power levels.
• You can be completely immune if you have enough numerical resistance vs. the power level, but you can also have a partial % resistance chance if your resistance number is lower.
• Elemental resistance works much the same way. You have a rating and if it's high enough it'll reduce damage by the maximum 60%, but if your rating is lower, the % resist will also be. If it's too low, it'll be a 0% resist versus that source.

• the towns are mini-maps you walk around in now. It adds very little except access to a couple of mini-dungeons.

• There is only one magic shop in one town. It still costs crystals and never restocks. The items are really good, though. Instead, you can buy lesser magic items from specialty "guild" shops in every town for cash. I found a few good items, but they seem to be randomly generated on game start and most are therefore trash. You still have to find the captured artisan somewhere in the world before there's much in stock in the specific shop. The first town has the guy hidden up north in a dangerous dungeon that you won't get to until at least halfway through the game, and the items are pretty worthless by then. The other shops don't have the same problem.

Feel free to ask questions.
Last edited by Rand on January 6th, 2024, 21:02, edited 5 times in total.
User avatar
Dorateen
Turtle
Turtle
Posts: 49
Joined: Sep 29, '23

Post by Dorateen »

Like the first game, the difficulty should be set for Hard not Normal to get the most out of combat.
User avatar
Acrux
Turtle
Turtle
Posts: 2038
Joined: Feb 8, '23

Post by Acrux »

A bit disappointed in the Archer, but Chris said he's planning a rebalance for the 1.2 or 1 3 release
It would be nice if the game kept notes about where you found important people like skill trainers
It does.
User avatar
maidenhaver
Posts: 4258
Joined: Apr 17, '23
Location: ROLE PLAYING GAME
Contact:

Post by maidenhaver »

I never completed it. I did the wizard towers, and then quit for some reason. It wasn't challenging at all. I don't play games, so I'm not an expert, but there should be more to wizard towers than bad guys and crystals. I expected traps and gimmicks. Hope the 2nd is the first one with better dungeons.
User avatar
rusty_shackleford
Site Admin
Posts: 10278
Joined: Feb 2, '23
Contact:

Post by rusty_shackleford »

No way to send your score in to the developer and be added to the hall of legends? I thought this was supposed to be like the M&M games!
User avatar
Rand
Posts: 1652
Joined: Sep 4, '23
Location: On my last legs

Post by Rand »

1998 wrote: December 17th, 2023, 15:13
How long was your playthrough?
Hard to tell as I didn't play it for very long at a time. Maybe about 20 hours.
User avatar
Rand
Posts: 1652
Joined: Sep 4, '23
Location: On my last legs

Post by Rand »

maidenhaver wrote: December 16th, 2023, 19:57
I never completed it. I did the wizard towers, and then quit for some reason. It wasn't challenging at all. I don't play games, so I'm not an expert, but there should be more to wizard towers than bad guys and crystals. I expected traps and gimmicks. Hope the 2nd is the first one with better dungeons.
It isn't. It's only slightly improved in the layouts, but there's still no intellectual difficulty to the dungeons/towers.
Last edited by Rand on December 17th, 2023, 23:19, edited 1 time in total.
User avatar
Rand
Posts: 1652
Joined: Sep 4, '23
Location: On my last legs

Post by Rand »

Dorateen wrote: December 16th, 2023, 19:23
Like the first game, the difficulty should be set for Hard not Normal to get the most out of combat.
I'm not sure this would make a useful difference to the combat gameplay.
So much of the time you're attacking a horde of enemies when you're overleveled as compared to them, this would mean that you'd just break off and rest more often.

Then when you're fighting the tough stuff, it's just random if they get a crit and end one or more of your characters.
And reviving someone in combat leaves them super weak (basically no damage ability for the rest of the fight) and almost completely devoid of health. Odds are they'll just die again before you can heal them.

But I'm curious what the actual experience is, so let us know if you do play on hard.
Last edited by Rand on December 17th, 2023, 23:25, edited 1 time in total.
User avatar
Rand
Posts: 1652
Joined: Sep 4, '23
Location: On my last legs

Post by Rand »

Acrux wrote: December 16th, 2023, 19:26
A bit disappointed in the Archer, but Chris said he's planning a rebalance for the 1.2 or 1 3 release
It would be nice if the game kept notes about where you found important people like skill trainers
It does.
Not anywhere that I could see.
User avatar
Acrux
Turtle
Turtle
Posts: 2038
Joined: Feb 8, '23

Post by Acrux »

Technically, @WhiteShark and I consider a review like this an "impression" rather than an official review since it doesn't follow our guidelines: viewtopic.php?t=461-want-to-write-a-review-start-here (They hadn't been formalized at the time.)

If you mean for the curator, I think some people were a little more positive, like@Kalarion. I haven't played it since the rebalance a few weeks ago.
Last edited by Acrux on April 26th, 2024, 12:37, edited 1 time in total.
User avatar
Dorateen
Turtle
Turtle
Posts: 49
Joined: Sep 29, '23

Post by Dorateen »

This review is for the sequel, which I haven't played yet. I expect I will have a favorable experience as I enjoyed the first, and I am looking forward to the Archer class and the town exploration.
User avatar
rusty_shackleford
Site Admin
Posts: 10278
Joined: Feb 2, '23
Contact:

Post by rusty_shackleford »

@Rand I moved this to the RPG forum because it's more of an impression than a review, no offense intended(this was per @Acrux's own words.) Just cleaning up the review section.
User avatar
Rand
Posts: 1652
Joined: Sep 4, '23
Location: On my last legs

Post by Rand »

rusty_shackleford wrote: Yesterday, 15:25
@Rand I moved this to the RPG forum because it's more of an impression than a review, no offense intended(this was per @Acrux's own words.) Just cleaning up the review section.
No problem
Post Reply